Barnaby Rudge: Analysis of Setting
"Barnaby Rudge: Analysis of Setting" explores the contrasting environments in Charles Dickens's novel, illustrating how various locations reflect the larger themes of society and human experience. Central to the narrative is the Maypole Inn, an old establishment that serves as a communal hub, portraying warmth and togetherness despite underlying tensions within the innkeeper's family. The setting shifts to London, characterized as a dark and complex labyrinth, where the past's rural charm is overshadowed by present-day squalor and crime, evoking a sense of nostalgia juxtaposed with harsh reality. The decaying Warren mansion symbolizes lost potential and Dickens's personal history, while Gabriel Varden's workshop, the Golden Key, embodies both honest labor and conflict, showcasing Dickens's critique of societal roles. Newgate Prison exemplifies the injustices of the legal system, reflecting the dire consequences of societal failures. Additionally, the apprentices' underground meeting place and the idle Paper Buildings further illustrate the complexities of ambition and morality in the urban landscape. Overall, the settings in "Barnaby Rudge" serve to deepen the reader's understanding of the characters and the turbulent times they navigate, highlighting themes of community, decay, and the struggle between nature and society.
Barnaby Rudge: Analysis of Setting
First published: 1841
Type of work: Novel
Type of plot: Historical
Time of work: 1775-1780
Asterisk denotes entries on real places.
Places Discussed
Maypole Inn
Maypole Inn. Old building near the real English village of Chigwell, twelve miles northeast of London. It is believed to be based on an actual Chigwell inn, the King’s Head, that Charles Dickens liked to visit. However, Dickens gave it the name of another inn found in the neighboring village of Chigwell Row. The inn is the site of a homelike little community in which the innkeeper, John Willett, enjoys the company of his regular customers. Its bar is a snug, cozy place, and fragrant odors emanating from its kitchen, along with the pleasant hum of voices and warm glow of the fireplace in its common room, make it a tempting refuge from stormy weather for Gabriel Varden, the traveling locksmith. When participants in the Gordon Riots attack the inn, the damage they cause seems to be a desecration of an almost sacred place.
However, the inn also has gloomy stables and grotesque carvings. Its timbers are decaying, and its bricks have become yellow and discolored. Homelike though it may seem at times, the Maypole is actually no longer a home but a commercial establishment, and its convivial community is repeatedly disrupted by antagonism between John Willett and his son Joe. The complex world of the Maypole reflects the larger world of England in being both flawed and enticing. Its attempted destruction, however, is clearly portrayed as a horrifying crime.
*London
*London. Like his portrayal of Maypole Inn, Dickens’s portrayal of London is contradictory. His first description of it comes after a scene in which the Maypole’s appealing aspects are emphasized. In contrast, London is described as a dark shadow and a labyrinth, lit by its own lights rather than Heaven’s. It is as if this urban world is less wholesome and blessed than the rural world of the Maypole.
Praise of the rural world and Nature, in contrast to the city, continues a few pages later, but this time the picture is complicated by another contrast: between the London of 1775 and the London of Dickens’s own time. The earlier London is much more rural than the London of 1841. Fields, trees, and gardens are nearby; Nature is not far off; merry hay-making goes on. This London, says the narrator, is purer and fresher than its modern, squalid descendant. However, in a later chapter the presence of fields in the London of 1775 suddenly shows a bad side because it is easy for thieves to escape into the fields. Moreover, the London of 1775 is so poorly lighted at night that crime is rife, making the streets unsafe at night. Eighteenth century London is also the place of such vices as gambling.
It is not entirely clear whether Dickens wants his readers to prefer the old London to the new, or even if he wants them to prefer Nature to the town. What is clear, though, is that however flawed London is, the riots that nearly destroy it are worse: the London the rioters create is a hellish, horrifying one of a city set ablaze.
Warren
Warren. Decaying, melancholy mansion near the Maypole Inn whose owner was murdered years earlier. Unlike the Maypole, which is restored after the riots, the Warren is reduced to ruins, perhaps reflecting its sad past, perhaps reflecting Dickens’s unhappy personal memories of working as a child in Warren’s Blacking Warehouse, whose name he borrowed for the mansion.
Golden Key
Golden Key. Combined home and workshop of the locksmith, Gabriel Varden, in Clerkenwell, a suburb of London. Another site of contradiction: at times a jovial place of honest labor, at other times a place of antagonism between Gabriel and his wife, his wife’s maid, and his apprentice. There is also some contradiction in the fact that Gabriel’s honest labor is in the service of creating locks for such unsavory uses as prison doors.
*Newgate Prison
*Newgate Prison. Notorious London prison. A harsh example of the social order: it holds prisoners condemned to death for trivial crimes and is a major target of the Gordon rioters in the novel.
Apprentices’ meeting place
Apprentices’ meeting place. Underground rooms in the Barbican district of London where Simon Tappertit, Gabriel Varden’s apprentice, chairs meetings of apprentices devoted to overthrowing society. The rooms are nastily unpleasant, suiting the nastiness of the apprentices’ plans.
*Paper Buildings
*Paper Buildings. Actual buildings in the Temple district of London. They have a lazy air to them, appropriate to Sir John Chester, an idle, hypocritical gentleman who lives there.
Rudges’ later home
Rudges’ later home. Poor cottage in a small unnamed country town where Barnaby Rudge and his mother live after fleeing London in 1775. Barnaby wanders happily in the neighboring fields; Nature here seems idyllic—except the sunlit clouds make Barnaby think of gold and lead to his involvement in the riots.
Bibliography
Adrian, Arthur A. Dickens and the Parent-Child Relationship. Athens: Ohio University Press, 1984. Explores the effect of the cruelty of parents who withhold their love and ignore their children’s feelings. Views Barnaby Rudge as a study of “father-son friction.”
Kincaid, James R. Dickens and the Rhetoric of Laughter. Oxford, England: Clarendon Press, 1971. Includes an excellent chapter on Barnaby Rudge that explores the nature of the humor in the novel. Suggests that Dickens wants the reader to laugh at tyranny.
Lindsay, Jack. “Barnaby Rudge.” In Dickens and the Twentieth Century, edited by John Gross and Gabriel Pearson. London: Routledge, 1962. Reconsiders Barnaby Rudge, treating the novel as a study of the nature of social change.
Newman, S. J. Dickens at Play. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1981. A good treatment of Barnaby Rudge that interprets the riots as a vision of the nature of anarchy. Focuses on the “unwilling collusion between madness and creativity” in the character of Lord Gordon.
Rice, Thomas J. “The Politics of Barnaby Rudge.” In The Changing World of Charles Dickens, edited by Robert Giddings. New York: Barnes & Noble, 1983. An excellent essay that firmly grounds the writing of Barnaby Rudge in the political situation of its time.