Panspermia
Panspermia is a hypothesis proposing that life on Earth originated from microorganisms or chemical precursors of life arriving from outer space. This concept encompasses various theories, including naturalistic panspermia, where life was ejected from its original site in the universe and arrived on Earth by chance, and directed panspermia, which suggests that intelligent extraterrestrial beings intentionally seeded Earth with life. Additionally, there is the intelligent design variant, which posits that advanced aliens not only discovered Earth but also engineered the conditions necessary for life to develop.
While the panspermia hypothesis has historically been viewed with skepticism due to a lack of concrete evidence, recent astronomical discoveries have reignited interest in the idea. Findings such as organic compounds in space and unusual traces in meteorites, including the Allan Hills 84001 meteorite from Mars, support the possibility of cosmic life origins. Moreover, certain microorganisms have demonstrated resilience to the extreme conditions of space travel, lending credence to the idea that life could survive such journeys. Despite its controversial status, panspermia continues to be explored as a potential explanation for the origins of life on Earth and is considered more plausible as new research unfolds.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Panspermia
The panspermia hypothesis is a set of related theories speculating that life arrived on Earth from sources in outer space. The hypothesis takes multiple forms, with some suggesting that microbes frozen into comets or meteors landed on Earth by chance and flourished here upon their arrival. Others posit that Earth was deliberately chosen by advanced extraterrestrials and purposely seeded or colonized with life.
The unproven panspermia hypothesis is a controversial topic. While a lack of compelling evidence left the theory on the fringes of the scientific mainstream for many years, panspermia-related ideas have enjoyed renewed popularity as astronomers and astrobiologists have discovered that organic chemical compounds are far more abundant in deep space than they initially believed. Recent research and scientific discoveries, including strange traces found on a meteorite of Martian origin in 1996, also seem to offer evidence in support of the panspermia hypothesis.
Background
The earliest known variation of the panspermia hypothesis was forwarded by the ancient Greek philosopher Anaxagoras, who theorized that all things originally existed in small, fragmentary bits of their present forms. Anaxagoras conceived of these fragments as being akin to seeds, from which the multitudinous configurations of life on Earth later grew. Although Anaxagoras did not explicitly state a belief that these seeds originated in outer space, he did think of them as being sourced from a primordial and complex mass that evolved and differentiated over time to form the world and all things in it.
The modern conception of the panspermia theory can be traced to the early 1870s, when the British mathematical physicist William Thompson, Lord Kelvin and the German physicist Hermann von Helmholtz first forwarded the argument that life may have originated in outer space. Lord Kelvin and Helmholtz built their ideas on research published in 1864 by the French chemist and biologist Louis Pasteur, who disproved the then popular theory that microbial life generated spontaneously. In the early twentieth century, the Nobel Prize–winning Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius then posited that life on Earth arose from bacterial spores that were impelled through outer space by the pressure caused by light waves.
In the 1970s, the British astronomers Nalin Chandra Wickramasinghe and Fred Hoyle conducted a series of detailed spectroscopic studies of the light emitted by distant celestial bodies, and claimed that these light clouds contained evidence of the building blocks of life. They also developed a theory speculating that basic forms of bacterial life are able to travel through space on comets, and are protected from radiation by thick water-ice covers. Their groundbreaking work led the scientific community to widely accept the notion that the elementary chemical compounds seen in living organisms indeed exist in outer space. Many researchers have since taken up the question of life's possible cosmic ancestry, with leading experts including Richard Dawkins and Stephen Hawking among those who have publicly endorsed the panspermia theory.
Overview
Contemporary versions of the panspermia hypothesis exist in three main forms: naturalistic panspermia, directed panspermia, and intelligent design panspermia.
Naturalistic panspermia is the idea that life-forms evolved elsewhere in the universe and were ejected from their sites of origin by natural processes that led to their discharge into outer space. From there, they traveled through space and arrived on Earth by chance, where they found favorable conditions that enabled them to reawaken, evolve, and complexify. A variation of this theory holds that passing comets and meteors are constantly introducing new forms of microbial life to Earth.
Directed panspermia theories posit that intelligent alien beings purposefully seeded Earth, and possibly other planets, with their own life-forms. These theories are typically built on the notion that advanced extraterrestrials sought to spread life to other places in the universe because their home planets were depleted of resources, nearing the end of their life cycles, or were becoming inhospitable for other reasons. However, directed panspermia ideas are wildly theoretical, untested and are impossible to prove or disprove. As such, they have yet to gain any serious traction within the scientific community.
The intelligent design version of the panspermia hypothesis holds that advanced beings from elsewhere in the universe discovered and traveled to Earth, where they designed and started the processes that led to the development of earthly life. All three forms of the panspermia theory intend to bridge perceived gaps in prevailing origin-of-life models.
Thus far, panspermia theories have met with skepticism. However, recent research and scientific discoveries may offer some support to the cosmic ancestry hypothesis. One well-known instance occurred in 1996, when the Allan Hills 84001 meteorite, which originated on Mars, was found to contain what appeared to be fossilized remnants of bacteria. Skeptics contended that the fossils have earthly origins and were transposed onto the rock by events that took place sometime during the 13,000 years the meteorite lay undiscovered in Antarctica. Others have claimed that the trace remains in the meteorite were misidentified as fossils and are actually residues of the original explosion that led to the rock's ejection from the Martian landscape. However, in 2009, researchers revisited the meteorite with powerful new microscopes and found further unusual physical and chemical traces that appear to disprove both of the skeptical explanations for the fossil-like anomalies.
In 2013, a high-altitude balloon circulating 16 miles (23 kilometers) above Earth accumulated the apparent remains of biological material that some scientists believe was released into the upper atmosphere by passing meteors. Additional unexplained organic compounds have also been recovered from other samples drawn from the upper atmosphere. Another 2013 experiment found that Nannochloropsis oculata, a type of single-celled algae found in oceans, appears to be capable of withstanding the impact velocity that would occur if a comet or meteor crash-landed on Earth. Scientists associated with the experiment theorized that the rock and ice from which comets and meteors are made would shield such microorganisms from the radiation and extreme temperatures they would encounter during travel through space.
Despite this evidence, the panspermia hypothesis is still unproven. However, it is also increasingly considered credible, particularly if the comets or meteors carrying the building blocks of life would only have been required to travel relatively short distances before reaching Earth. In addition to Mars, astronomers and astrobiologists have identified the Saturnian moons of Enceladus and Titan and the Jovian moons of Callisto, Europa, and Ganymede as the solar system's leading candidates for currently or formerly housing extraterrestrial lifeforms.
Bibliography
Davies, Paul. The 5th Miracle: The Search for the Origin and Meaning of Life. Simon and Schuster, 2015.
Gannon, Megan. "Did Earth Life Come from Space? Tough Algae Suggests Panspermia Possibility." Space.com, 23 Sept. 2013, www.space.com/22880-life-from-space-panspermia-possibility.html. Accessed 13 Nov. 2017.
Kaufman, Mark. "In Search of Panspermia." NASA, 6 Jan. 2017, astrobiology.nasa.gov/news/in-search-of-panspermia/. Accessed 13 Nov. 2017.
Leach, Ben. "Bacteria from Mars Found Inside Ancient Meteorite." Telegraph, 26 Nov. 2009, www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/science-news/6660045/Bacteria-from-Mars-found-inside-ancient-meteorite.html. Accessed 13 Nov. 2017.
O'Leary, Margaret. Anaxagoras and the Origin of Panspermia Theory. iUniverse, 2008.
Orwig, Jessica. "Sending Humans to Mars Could Uncover a Disturbing Truth to One of Life's Greatest Mysteries." Business Insider, 8 Dec. 2015, www.businessinsider.fr/us/panspermia-theory-posits-life-on-earth-could-come-from-mars-2015-11/. Accessed 13 Nov. 2017.
"Problems with Panspermia or Extraterrestrial Origins-of-Life Scenarios." Intelligent Design and Evolutionary Awareness (IDEA) Center, www.ideacenter.org/contentmgr/showdetails.php/id/849. Accessed 13 Nov. 2017.
Spall, Nick. "Panspermia: Could Life Be Delivered to a Planet?" BBC Sky at Night, 15 Nov. 2023, www.skyatnightmagazine.com/space-science/panspermia-life-theory. Accessed 18 Nov. 2024.