Enclave economies
Enclave economies refer to economic systems where members of a specific minority group come together to establish businesses that cater primarily to their own community. This clustering is often fueled by a strong sense of social cohesion and loyalty among group members, which helps sustain these businesses against external competition. The formation of such economies offers a pathway for economic mobility, enabling individuals within the group to access goods, services, and job opportunities that may not be available in the broader market.
Research has highlighted various ethnic communities, such as Cuban Americans in Miami and Chinese Americans in New York City's Chinatown, illustrating how these enclaves can lead to significant economic advancements for their members by creating supportive networks. However, discussions around enclave economies are nuanced, with some scholars addressing potential issues such as exploitation within these economies and questioning their long-term sustainability as members may eventually seek opportunities outside the enclave. Overall, enclave economies serve as a vital alternative for minority groups striving for economic achievement in often challenging circumstances.
On this Page
Enclave economies
In an enclave economy, entrepreneurs from a single minority group cluster together and form a market that supplies others in the same group with goods, services, and jobs. The emergence of an enclave economy is attributed to the existence of a high level of social cohesion among members of a given racial or ethnic group. This solidarity generates loyalty to businesses owned and operated by people from the same ethnic group, insulating them from outside competition. As a result, enclave economies are able to expand and diversify over time, generating wealth and upward mobility for members of a given racial or ethnic group. In fact, enclave economies are considered to offer minority group members an alternative route to economic attainment, allowing for economic mobility outside the mainstream economy.
Scholars have examined economic activity and entrepreneurship in various racial and ethnic communities in order to better understand enclave economies. Some of the most pivotal research in this area has focused on the Cuban community in Miami. In Latin Journeys (1985), sociologist Alejandro Portes and coauthor Robert L. Bach describe how Cuban refugees initially found low-paying jobs at the bottom of the US economy, but eventually, the concentration of Cubans in Miami allowed many to move up the job ladder by pursuing employment and entrepreneurship within the Cuban community. Portes and Bach argue that the presence of an ethnic market in Miami allowed many Cuban refugees to make economic gains that would have otherwise been impossible.
Similarly, in Chinatown (1992), sociologist Min Zhou describes how the agglomeration of businesses owned by ethnic Chinese in New York City’s Chinatown has generated economic opportunities for Chinese Americans. She points out that although Chinatown’s residents have origins in such disparate regions as Taiwan, Hong Kong, mainland China, and Southeast Asia, a common ethnic identity stabilizes the enclave economy. Zhou's analysis highlights the central role of ethnic solidarity in the production and maintenance of economic enclaves, arguing that group cohesion among ethnic Chinese stabilizes Chinatown’s enclave economy.
There remains a great deal of scholarly debate concerning enclave economies. In The New Chinatown (1987), sociologist and journalist Peter Kwong describes how the perceived prosperity of an enclave economy can mask the extent to which its success is dependent on the exploitation of members of the group, particularly where employee-employer relations are concerned. Other scholars question the permanence of individual enclave economies, such as sociologist and business professor John Sibley Butler, who points out in Entrepreneurship and Self-Help among Black Americans (1991) that in the past, minority groups have developed enclave economies only to see them decline as subsequent generations abandoned the ethnic enclave for opportunities in the mainstream economy.
Bibliography
Butler, John Sibley. Entrepreneurship and Self-Help among Black Americans: A Reconsideration of Race and Economics. Rev. ed., State U of New York P, 2005.
"Enclave Economy." Economic Point, economicpoint.com/enclave-economy. Accessed 15 Dec. 2024.
Kwong, Peter. The New Chinatown. Rev. ed., Hill, 1996.
Portes, Alejandro, and Robert L. Bach. Latin Journeys: Cuban and Mexican Immigrants in the United States. U of California P, 1985.
Zhou, Min. Chinatown: The Socioeconomic Potential of an Urban Enclave. Temple UP, 1992.