Hedging
Hedging is a risk management strategy used by investors to mitigate potential losses in their primary investments. It involves taking a position that contrasts with one's main investment strategy to offset the risks associated with it. While this approach can limit potential losses, it also caps potential gains, creating a balance that investors must navigate carefully. A common example of hedging can be seen in gambling, where a bettor might wager on both red and black in roulette to ensure some return regardless of the outcome.
Historically, the term "hedge" originates from Old English, referring to barriers that separate properties, metaphorically evolving to signify protection against perceived threats. In agriculture, farmers utilize hedging techniques, such as futures contracts, to secure prices for their crops ahead of harvest, thus managing the risks posed by unpredictable market conditions and crop yields.
Hedge funds represent a specific type of investment vehicle designed to enable profits regardless of market direction, highlighting the dual nature of hedging as both a protective measure and a potential constraint on earnings. However, the complexities of hedging were notably scrutinized during the 2008 financial crisis, as excessive and irresponsible hedging practices involving high-risk mortgages were implicated in broader economic instability. Thus, effective hedging requires careful consideration of risk and return dynamics.
On this Page
Hedging
Hedging is a strategy for risk management employed by investors in order to moderate their level of risk. Hedging involves the adoption of an investment position or decision that is contrary to one’s primary investment strategy. This is to offset the potential risk of one’s primary investment failing to return a substantial profit, or worse yet, returning a substantial loss instead. Hedging thus allows the investor to place a limitation upon his or her potential losses, but because it is based on investing "in the opposite direction" from one’s primary investment, it also entails a limitation on potential gains. A gambler at the roulette wheel, in which a ball lands on red or black, offers an example of hedging by placing a one hundred dollar bet on black and an additional twenty dollar bet on red. This guarantees that at a minimum, the gambler will receive the profits of the twenty dollar bet.
Background
The origin of the word hedge is from Old English, and refers to a fence constructed out of dense bushes, used to separate one landowner’s fields from those of another. It has also been used to refer to any kind of barrier between one area and an adjacent area. Beginning in the seventeenth century, hedging began to be used in a metaphorical sense with regard to erecting a barrier between oneself and some perceived threat. From this it has developed its modern sense of referring to the evasion of risk or harm.
Hedging often arises in the context of farmers who must try to anticipate how their own crops will perform (subject to unpredictable fluctuations in the weather, pests, and so forth) and how the market for those crops will perform at the time the farmer is ready to bring his or her crops to market for sale. These calculations involve a substantial amount of uncertainty, which from the farmer’s perspective creates risk that he or she would like to manage. If things go well and the farmer’s crops produce an abundant yield, and the market is favorable at harvest time, then there may be a sizable profit above and beyond what was anticipated. On the other hand, if the crops have a low yield or the market for the crops is saturated at harvest time, then the farmer may earn far less than had been hoped. Farmers have a long term orientation to their profession, so in most cases they are not willing to balance a large potential gain against an equally large potential loss; after all, a loss that is too great could very well put them out of business permanently. Therefore, farmers often seek to moderate their risk, by locking in a moderate price for their crops through the use of a futures contract, which is a form of hedging.
In a futures contract, for example, the farmer might face two possibilities, assuming his crops perform well enough to make it to market: a strong market, where he or she can make ten thousand dollars for the crops, or a weak market, where he or she can make only two thousand dollars for the same crops. If the farmer feels that the risk of earning only two thousand dollars is too great to justify the possibility of earning five times that, then the farmer may contract with a buyer so that the buyer agrees in advance to buy the farmer’s output for five thousand dollars. Doing this means that the farmer agrees to give up the possibility of the ten thousand dollar sale in order to be able to hedge against the possibility of the two thousand dollar sale.
Overview
Hedge funds are investment instruments that are designed to make it possible for investors to realize a profit on their investment without regard to whether the market goes up or goes down. The investors are presumably hedged against risk from either direction. Hedging was a major topic in the news in 2008 and several years thereafter because of the role that hedge funds and their managers played in the global financial crisis. The controversy and subsequent crisis involved hedge funds using subprime (high risk) mortgages as investment vehicles. Banks and financial institutions had accelerated the practice of approving mortgages that were likely to be defaulted on, and then offsetting that risk through the customary practice of hedging. Because mortgagees have a large personal stake in homeownership and the effects of the financial crisis fell most heavily on them, financial institutions in the aftermath were perceived as having made predatory loans to applicants who were clearly unable to responsibly manage the debt they were taking on, and then "betting against" those mortgages being paid off.
For financial institutions, however, hedging is a sensible practice, and one that most investors and bank customers would hope or even demand that their institutions engage in, since failing to do so could place investors’ funds at greater risk. As demonstrated by the subprime mortgage catastrophe, immoderate hedging can potentially cut into profits to such a degree that the whole investment no longer makes sense. Hedging requires one to walk a fine line between risk that is too high and return on investment that is too low.
Bibliography
Barnes, Ryan. “The Fuel That Fed the Subprime Meltdown.” Investopedia, 27 Aug. 2023, www.investopedia.com/articles/07/subprime-overview.asp. Accessed 26 Dec. 2024.
Batten, Jonathan, Peter MacKay, and Niklas F. Wagner. Advances in Financial Risk Management: Corporates, Intermediaries and Portfolios. Palgrave, 2013.
“Beginner's Guide to Hedging: Definition and Example of Hedges in Finance.” Investopedia, 16 June 2024, www.investopedia.com/trading/hedging-beginners-guide/. Accessed 26 Dec. 2024.
Bodie, Zvi, Alex Kane, and Alan J. Marcus. Investments. McGraw, 2014.
Das, Satyajit. Extreme Money: Masters of the Universe and the Cult of Risk. FT Press, 2012.
Garner, Carley. A Trader's First Book on Commodities: An Introduction to the World's Fastest Growing Market. FT Press, 2013.
“Hedge Definition and How It Works in Investing.” Investopedia, 23 June 2024, www.investopedia.com/terms/h/hedge.asp. Accessed 26 Dec. 2024.
Hull, John. Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives. Prentice, 2012.
Pinedo, Michael, and Ingo Walter. Global Asset Management: Strategies, Risks, Processes and Technologies. Palgrave, 2013.
Poitras, Geoffrey. Commodity Risk Management: Theory and Application. Routledge, 2013.
Scaramucci, Anthony. The Little Book of Hedge Funds: What You Need to Know About Hedge Funds but the Managers Won't Tell You. Wiley, 2012.