Profit Sharing
Profit sharing is a business strategy where employees receive a share of the company's profits, typically during a specified period. This practice aims to motivate employees to enhance their commitment to the company, with the belief that when they have a stake in the company's success, they will work harder to ensure profitability. Various profit-sharing plans exist, including cash plans that provide immediate financial rewards and deferred plans that contribute to retirement funds, allowing for long-term investment growth.
Profit sharing can be particularly appealing for companies looking to attract and retain talent without incurring high costs associated with traditional benefits. However, its effectiveness is debated. Proponents argue that it aligns employee interests with company performance, while critics point out potential downsides, such as employees' lack of understanding of how their efforts influence profits and the equal distribution of benefits regardless of individual contribution. Additionally, the variable nature of profit sharing can lead to fluctuating employee expectations, potentially causing dissatisfaction during less profitable years. Overall, profit sharing serves as a unique incentive structure within corporate compensation strategies, reflecting diverse perspectives on employee engagement and motivation.
Profit Sharing
Profit sharing is a business practice in which a company’s employees share a portion of the business’s profits (income over expenditures) during a set time period. Many businesses offer profit sharing plans, or benefit plans that pay employees cash or help them to save for retirement. One main goal of profit sharing is to motivate employees to become more invested in the company and to encourage them to help the company generate increased profits. Supporters of profit sharing believe that if an employee receives a percentage of a company’s profits, that employee will feel more driven to work hard and help the company make as much money as possible.
Profit sharing plans can be especially popular for companies that want to attract or maintain talent but do not want or cannot afford to offer expensive employee benefits. Since profit sharing pays out only if the company makes a certain level of profit, the company does not have to compensate employees for the benefit if it does not perform as expected.
Types of Profit Sharing Plans
Companies utilize different types of profit sharing plans and allocate profits in different ways. A cash profit sharing plan offers cash or stock to participating employees for the year the company makes the profit. The cash or stock is paid in a manner similar to a salary check or a stock deposit into a stock account. The earnings made through cash profit sharing plans are generally taxed just like any other type of income.
In a deferred profit sharing plan, the profits due to employees are deferred into investment plans, such as retirement plans. Profit sharing retirement plans are one of the most popular types of deferred profit sharing plans. The profits set aside in these plans earn interest and grow over time. Employees generally cannot access the funds in these plans before retirement without being financially penalized for doing so.
Sometimes companies offer combination plans. In a combination plan, employees are offered cash or stock options, with some of the earnings earmarked for a deferred investment plan. In such plans, employees realize some immediate financial gain, but also benefit through the growth of a retirement fund over the long term.
Profit Sharing Retirement Plans
Profit sharing retirement plans are different from other types of company retirement plans in a few ways. Companies that offer profit sharing retirement plans often require employees to enroll in the plan. Participation is not voluntary. This differs from other types of retirement plans, such as 401Ks, in which employees choose whether or not they wish to participate.
Another difference is that contribution levels in profit sharing retirement programs are uncertain. Since a company’s profits may vary widely from year to year, the amount of earnings realized from the program can vary widely.
One final difference between profit sharing and other types of retirement plans involve taxes and fees. Profit sharing plans are taxed differently than other types of plans. Employees may have to pay more or less tax, depending on how the plan is set up.
Arguments and For and Against Profit Sharing
One reason profit sharing has become a popular business option is that it allows companies to offer employees benefits while keeping overall costs lower. Benefits such as profit sharing can help maintain a company’s talent without requiring as much investment as other types of benefits. Profit sharing plans may be offered to employees as an extra incentive, or they may be offered as the company’s only retirement investment program. Profit sharing also gives employees a common goal to work toward and encourages them to focus on the company’s reputation and overall performance.
Another argument in support of profit sharing is that it gives small businesses a way to attract high-quality employees. Businesses are constantly looking for ways to increase their attractiveness to high-performing individuals, especially if they are new or competing against larger, more established establishments.
Finally, the cost of profit sharing programs tracks along with the company’s performance. If the company performs less well than expected, the profit sharing benefit decreases. If a company performs better than expected, the profit sharing benefit increases. This keeps the benefit from impacting the company’s bottom line the way standard benefits might.
One argument against profit sharing is that it is not a good incentive for employees. Employees who receive profit sharing are supposed to help increase profits—and, therefore, increase their own income. However, many employees do not understand how their work actually affects the company’s bottom line. If employees do not understand how their work impacts results, they may not feel motivated to work harder or differently.
A second argument against profit sharing plans is that the employer does not have control over the amount of money employees receive. All employees—no matter their experience level or individual contribution—generally make the same amount from the benefit. Some experts feel this can be a disincentive to high performers and suggest that targeted benefits plans may be be more effective.
Finally, some experts argue that employees may come to expect the profit sharing funds they receive, even if the company does not perform well. Since profits rise and fall from one year to the next, it is likely that the benefits of profit sharing will fluctuate, too. If employees do not understand how this process works, they may be angry or upset in years that no profit sharing comes to them.
Bibliography
"Compensation: Incentive Plans: Profit Sharing." HR-Guide. HR-Guide, LLC. Web. 3 Mar 2016. http://www.hr-guide.com/data/G444.htm
"Profit-Sharing Plans." Employee Benefit Research Institute. Employee Benefit Research Institute. Web. 3 Mar 2016. https://www.ebri.org/pdf/publications/books/fundamentals/fund06.pdf
"Profit Sharing Plans for Small Businesses." Employee Benefits Security Administration, U.S Department of Labor. Web. 3 Mar 2016. http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/publications/profitsharing.html
Sahadi, Jeanne. "Profit sharing plan ABCs." CNN Money. CNN. 4 Oct. 2000. Web. 3 Mar 2016. http://money.cnn.com/2000/10/04/strategies/q‗retire‗profitshare
Stack, Jack. "The Problem with Profit Sharing." Inc. Mansueto Ventures. Web. 3 Mar 2016. http://www.inc.com/magazine/19961101/1864.html