Alkaline hydrolysis (body disposal)
Alkaline hydrolysis is an alternative method for body disposal that uses water, alkaline chemicals, heat, and sometimes pressure to accelerate the decomposition process. This technique transforms human remains into mineral ash and a liquid composed of organic compounds, which can be disposed of safely, while preserving more of the body than traditional cremation. Alkaline hydrolysis is often viewed as a more environmentally friendly option since it uses less energy and generates fewer emissions compared to cremation. The process typically takes between three to twelve hours and has gained popularity in the twenty-first century, with public figures like Desmond Tutu opting for it due to its eco-conscious approach.
Despite its benefits, alkaline hydrolysis has faced controversy and resistance in some regions, primarily due to concerns about wastewater treatment and perceptions regarding respect for human remains. It remains legal in over twenty states, with some funeral homes near state borders offering the service in states where it is permitted. Supporters highlight its lower environmental impact and cost-effectiveness compared to traditional burial or cremation, while opponents, including some religious leaders, argue that it lacks dignity. Overall, alkaline hydrolysis presents a complex blend of cultural, ethical, and environmental considerations in the realm of body disposal.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Alkaline hydrolysis (body disposal)
Alkaline hydrolysis is an alternative to cremation or burial. The process accelerates traditional decomposition using water, alkaline chemicals, heat, and sometimes pressure. Human bones become mineral ash. The rest of the body forms a liquid of organic compounds. Like cremation, alkaline hydrolysis costs less than burial and loved ones may keep the dry remains. However, alkaline hydrolysis uses less energy, produces fewer emissions, and preserves more of the person’s remains than cremation. In the twenty-first century, alkaline hydrolysis is becoming popular. Anti-apartheid leader Desmond Tutu, who died in January 2022, chose alkaline hydrolysis because he wanted to dispose of his remains in an environmentally friendly, affordable way.
Not all states in America allow alkaline hydrolysis. This is mainly because people are uncomfortable with the liquid going into wastewater treatment facilities or believe that the liquid will endanger the water supply, causing higher PH levels. Catholic leaders oppose the process because they feel that it does not dignify the human body.
Alkaline hydrolysis is also called AH, flameless cremation, water cremation, green cremation, chemical cremation, liquid cremation, or aquamation.
Background
Alkaline hydrolysis takes place inside a large metal chamber, where water and lye are heated and pressurized. The chemical reactions are like those in natural decomposition. However, the process takes three to twelve hours instead of years.
Alkaline hydrolysis dissolves flesh, blood, and muscle into a liquid consisting of salt, peptides, and amino acids, which can be drained from the chamber. After the liquid is drained, bones, dental fillings, and, if they exist, pacemakers and artificial joints like knees or hips remain. The bones are crushed into a powder and given to loved ones in an urn, just as in fire cremation. With alkaline hydrolysis, the dental fillings and medical equipment can be recycled. With fire cremation, on the other hand, dental fillings create air pollution and pacemakers are subject to explosions. Pacemakers often must be removed from the dead person’s body before cremation.
A farmer from Middlesex, England, named Amos Herbert Hanson developed alkaline hydrolysis in 1888 to dispose of animal carcasses. His method produced fertilizer that supported his agriculture. Scientific labs began using it one hundred years later to dispose of cows infected with mad cow disease. Not long after this, pet owners embraced the technology when saying goodbye to pets.
Albany Medical College in New York installed the first commercial system for human bodies in 1993. After that, other universities and hospitals began using alkaline hydrolysis to dispose of donated bodies. Minnesota legalized alkaline hydrolysis for human bodies in 2003. That same year, the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, became the first in the state to use alkaline hydrolysis. In 2011, funeral homes in Florida and Ohio began using it. However, Ohio has since withdrawn authorization for the process.
Overview
In the 2020s, alkaline hydrolysis has generated controversy in the United States. Some view it as an environmentally friendly, affordable way to dispose of remains. However, some businesses, state governments, and many Roman Catholics oppose it.
Some businesses within the funeral industry, such as those that manufacture caskets, oppose it. For example, Richard Hamm was a Republican member of the Indiana State House of Representatives and is the owner of two casket manufacturing companies. He painted a negative picture of alkaline hydrolysis, telling other members of the House that the process requires bodies to be dissolved in acid, which is then poured down the drain. The Indiana bill to allow alkaline hydrolysis failed after Hamm’s inaccurate speech.
Some states initially permitted alkaline hydrolysis but later reversed their decision. For example, New Hampshire allowed alkaline hydrolysis for only two years. This was also true of Ohio, where Roman Catholic leaders alleged that the process does not honor the dignity of the human body. They contended that traditional burial methods, including flame creation, showed more reverence for a person’s body.
Some oppose alkaline hydrolysis because they fear that health and safety issues could arise and believe more testing is needed to see how the process affects water quality. However, Florida has been using alkaline hydrolysis on human bodies since 2014, and testing in St. Petersburg, Florida, did not show any changes in water quality.
Supporters believe alkaline hydrolysis has significant environmental benefits. It produces less air pollution, emitting less mercury into the air than cremation. A 2011 University of Groningen study compared conventional burial, cremation, and alkaline hydrolysis. Overall, alkaline hydrolysis had the lowest environmental footprint of the methods tested. Moreover, it could produce fertilizer and water for irrigation. The current process for burial and cremations demands millions of tons in raw materials to make caskets and construct vaults. Moreover, millions of gallons of embalming fluid are used each year. These materials are all buried underground, which is not good for the environment.
In terms of cost, alkaline hydrolysis is an appealing option for customers. The cost is often similar to that of fire cremation, which is thousands of dollars less than burial in a casket. It also appeals more to some customers than fire creation, which uses flames to destroy a human body. These customers prefer the water-based alternative of alkaline hydrolysis.
By 2023, alkaline hydrolysis had become available in more than twenty states, and many other states were considering legalizing it. Additionally, some funeral homes near state borders offer it because they can drive across a state line into a state where it is legal.
Bibliography
Agence France-Presse. “What Is Aquamation? The Process behind Desmond Tutu’s ‘Green Cremation.’” The Guardian, 1 Jan. 2022, www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/02/what-is-aquamation-the-process-behind-desmond-tutus-green-cremation. Accessed 17 Feb. 2022.
Atkin, Emily. “The Fight for the Right to Be Cremated by Water.” New Republic, 14 June 2018, newrepublic.com/article/148997/fight-right-cremated-water-rise-alkaline-hydrolysis-america. Accessed 16 Feb. 2022.
Dower, Linsey. “Push to Legalize Water Cremation Resurfaces.” Honolulu Star Advertiser, 14 Feb. 2022, www.staradvertiser.com/2022/02/14/hawaii-news/push-to-legalize-water-cremation-resurfaces/. Accessed 17 Feb. 2022.
Keene, Valerie. “Alkaline Hydrolysis Laws in Your State.” NOLO, www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/alkaline-hydrolysis-laws-your-state.html Accessed. Accessed 17 Feb. 2022.
Nielsen, Steve. “Water Cremation: What Is Alkaline Hydrolysis and Why It’s More Environmentally Friendly.” Fox News,12 Jan. 2022, www.fox10phoenix.com/news/water-cremation-what-is-alkaline-hydrolysis-and-why-its-more-environmentally-friendly. Accessed 17 Feb. 2020.
Panecasio, Steph. “The Misunderstood Funeral Tech that’s Illegal in 30 States.” CNET, 1 June 2020, www.cnet.com/news/features/the-misunderstood-funeral-tech-thats-illegal-in-30-states/. Accessed 18 Feb. 2022.
Raymond, Chris. “How Alkaline Hydrolysis Works.” Very Well Health, 12 Mar. 2020, www.verywellhealth.com/what-is-alkaline-hydrolysis-1131908. Accessed Feb. 17, 2022.
Solomon, Adina. “More States Legalize Dissolving Bodies in Water.” US News, 12 Mar. 2020, www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/2020-03-12/more-states-legalize-alkaline-hydrolysis-dissolving-dead-bodies-in-water. Accessed 17 Feb. 2020.
Team Earth. "Tracker: Where Is Alkaline Hydrolysis Legal in the US?" Earth, 2 Feb. 2023, earthfuneral.com/resources/tracker-where-alkaline-hydrolysis-legal/. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.