Clathrates and climate change
Clathrates, often referred to as gas hydrates, are unique molecular structures where one type of molecule traps another without forming a chemical bond. The most common clathrates involve water trapping gases, particularly methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas. Climate change is significantly impacted by methane because its release can enhance the greenhouse effect, leading to global warming. Historical evidence suggests that large methane releases have triggered abrupt climate changes in the past, such as an event approximately 635 million years ago that caused significant warming.
Methane clathrates are typically found in ocean sediments and can be destabilized by temperature increases or pressure decreases, potentially releasing large quantities of methane into the atmosphere. This can have dangerous consequences, including further climate change and threats to aquatic life due to reduced oxygen levels. While the potential for harvesting methane clathrates for energy exists, it poses risks such as accidental releases and geological instability, which could trigger tsunamis or deadly explosions. Thus, safe extraction methods are crucial for exploring this energy source without exacerbating climate change or causing environmental disasters.
Subject Terms
Clathrates and climate change
Definition
A clathrate is a chemically constructed lattice structure in which one type of molecule traps and contains another type of molecule without forming a chemical bond. Clathrates may also be called gas hydrates (sometimes using the name of the gas, such as “methane clathrate”), host-guest complexes, or molecular compounds. They are sometimes referred to as “marsh gas.”
The most common types of clathrates are those involving water trapping a gas, such as methane, ethane, propane, isobutene, butane, nitrogen, carbon dioxide (CO2), or hydrogen sulfide. Methane trapped in water is the most common type of naturally occurring clathrate. Methane clathrates usually occur when in a low-oxygen environment is degraded by bacteria. This situation usually occurs under ice sheets in the ocean; usually, these structures are found in sediments. A clump of methane hydrate looks like a snowball, but at room temperature, the ball dissolves. It can even be lit on fire, as the methane inside the lattice structure burns.
Significance for Climate Change
Because methane is one of the greenhouse gases (GHGs), gases that trap warmth on Earth’s surface, the release of large amounts of methane could cause the Earth to become warmer. In the geologic past, sudden releases of large amounts of methane may have triggered abrupt climatic events. Geologists believe that about 635 million years ago, a large quantity of methane was released into the atmosphere from ice sheets that covered Earth. This release caused an abrupt global warming taking Earth from a cold, relatively stable climate to a very warm, still relatively stable climate. Scientists think this event quickly warmed the Earth by tens of degrees Celsius.
Sudden releases of methane could occur if either the temperature rises or the pressure falls on the sediment above the methane clathrate structure. Often, sediment continues to accumulate over the methane clathrate until the weight of the sediment causes the clathrate structure to become unstable, when it disintegrates into water and gas. The covering sediments then become unstable and release methane into the atmosphere. The methane reacts with oxygen to form CO2, which can kill any animals that need oxygen.
The US Geological Survey estimates that up to 8.5 million cubic kilometers of methane clathrate exist in the seafloor worldwide, more than in all other fossil combined, so methane clathrates are being investigated as a potential source of natural gas energy. However, getting to this energy source is dangerous, as the accidental release of methane into the atmosphere could be deadly in and of itself. In addition, a release of this sort could affect the global temperature or even cause tsunamis if landslides under the ocean were triggered. Safe methods of harvesting this resource would need to be developed, as methane can be very explosive. Deadly methane explosions have occurred in mines in Harlan County, Kentucky, in 2006, in Ulyanovskaya, Russia, in 2007, Vorkuta, Komi Republic, Russia, in 2016, Karaganda, Kazakhstan, in 2023, and Tehran, Iran, in 2024. A deadly house explosion occurred because of methane in Oak Grove, Alabama, in 2024 because the house was over a mine. Methane can also cause an “exploding lake,” such as Lake Kivu in Africa. There, the lake water interacts with volcanic gases to produce methane and CO2, which are potentially deadly when released.
Harvesting methane from under ice sheets for fuel requires two different approaches, both of which are potentially dangerous. With the depressurization method, holes are drilled into a layer of methane hydrate just under the ice, which releases pressure and causes the methane to flow up a pipe. This approach uses less energy than the other approach, that of thermal injection. Thermal injection involves pumping hot water into a deposit of methane, which destabilizes the structure of the methane clathrate. A promising future approach involves injecting CO2 into the hydrate formation, displacing the methane in the structure.
Bibliography
Bruggers, James and Lee Hedgepeth. "Federal Regulators Waited 7 Months to Investigate a Deadly Home Explosion Above a Gassy Coal Mine. Residents Want Action." Inside Climate News, 3 Nov. 2024, insideclimatenews.org/news/03112024/federal-regulators-slow-to-investigate-alabama-deadly-mine-explosion/. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
“Clathrate Hydrates: Icy Fuel Thawed with Antifreeze Proteins.” Canadian Chemical News, May 1, 2006.
Kennedy, M., D. Mrofka, and C. von der Borch. “Snowball Earth Termination by Destabilization of Equatorial Permafrost Methane Clathrate.” Nature 453 (May 29, 2008): 642-645.
Kennett, J. P., ed. Methane Hydrates in Quaternary Climate Change: The Clathrate Gun Hypothesis. Washington, D.C.: American Geophysical Union, 2002.
Maynard, B. “Methane Hydrates: Energy Source of the Future?” Popular Mechanics, April, 2006.
Sloan, E. Dendy, Jr. Clathrate Hydrates of Natural Gases. Boca Raton, Fla.: CRC Press, 2008.
Weber, E. Molecular Inclusion and Molecular Recognition: Clathrates I. New York: Springer, 1987.
Weitemeyer, K. A., and B. A. Buffett. “Accumulation and Release of Methane from Clathrates Below the Laurentide and Cordilleran Ice Sheets.” In Global and Planetary Change. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Elsevier, 2006.