Homeopathic remedies for bruises
Homeopathic remedies for bruises involve the use of highly diluted substances to address damage to blood vessels resulting from injuries or surgeries. A bruise manifests as visible dark spots on the skin due to bleeding beneath, typically evolving in color from dark purple to greenish-yellow before fading away. Arnica montana is the most studied homeopathic remedy for bruising and is commonly found in homes, particularly in Europe. While many people advocate for its effectiveness, scientific evaluations have yielded mixed results, with some studies suggesting potential benefits and others finding no significant effects. Traditional homeopathic practices recommend Arnica for symptoms like bruising and discomfort. In addition to Arnica, bromelain—a natural enzyme from pineapple—has shown promise in reducing bruising, though further research is necessary. Other homeopathic options include remedies like Bella perennis and Ledum palustre, but these lack substantial scientific validation. Overall, while the use of homeopathic remedies for bruises is widely practiced, evidence of their efficacy remains inconclusive.
Homeopathic remedies for bruises
DEFINITION: The use of highly diluted remedies to treat damage to blood vessels from injury or surgery. The bleeding leads to the development of blood-containing tissue.
STUDIED HOMEOPATHIC REMEDY:Arnica
Introduction
A bruise is the visible evidence of bleeding under the skin. Seldom more than a cosmetic nuisance, it goes through a well-defined series of changes, beginning with a dark purple and red coloration and gradually fading to a greenish-yellow color before disappearing. Some people are particularly prone to bruises, developing them after injuries that are too minor to affect most people.
Scientific Evaluations of Homeopathic Remedies
Homeopathic Arnica is widely believed to be an effective treatment for bruises and other minor traumas, and it is found in the medicine cabinets of millions of people, especially in Europe. However, there is no consistent scientific evidence that it is effective.
For example, two preliminary clinical trials were performed to test whether homeopathic Arnica montana could reduce the size or discomfort of a bruise caused by injury. The first study tested 10m (quintamillesimal-scale) potency Arnica (equivalent to a dilution of one part in 1,020,000); the second used a 30c (centesimal) dilution. About twenty-five persons were enrolled in the two trials.
In these unpleasant-sounding experiments, the participants allowed themselves to be bruised on the inside of their forearms by a 2.3-pound (1,041-gram) weight, which fell from about 1.5 feet (44 centimeters) above the arm. Participants were given either Arnica or a placebo before the experiment and then were bruised on one arm. Subsequently, they were given a second dose of whatever they had just received and followed for three to four days. The goal was to see whether the bruises treated with Arnica got better faster than those treated by placebo. Researchers found a hint of benefit in the first study but none in the second. The number of participants in each study was too small to allow the results to have much statistical meaning.
Another study of people undergoing treatment for varicose veins, along with a study of people undergoing hand surgery, also failed to find the benefit of using Arnica to reduce bruising. In a double-blind trial of 130 people undergoing treatment for varicose veins, researchers found no benefit with homeopathic Arnica at 5x (decimal-scale) potency compared with placebo.
In a study involving face-lift surgery, researchers found equivocal benefits at best. However, in a meta-analysis of twenty-five studies primarily performed in the first two decades of the twenty-first century, eighteen studies found positive results for Arnica's use.
Finally, researchers have attempted to discover whether homeopathic Arnica 10x has any effect on the ability of the blood to clot, as measured by laboratory tests. In a double-blind study of eighteen healthy male volunteers, Arnica was indistinguishable from placebo regarding blood coagulation.
Traditional Homeopathic Treatments
Homeopathic practitioners traditionally give Arnica to treat traumatic injuries. The classical homeopathic symptom picture for Arnica includes the presence of black-and-blue spots, a bruised feeling, and difficulty finding a comfortable position. It is not difficult to recognize this as a description of a minor injury.
Bromelain, a combination of enzymes, has also been proposed as a natural remedy for bruising. In one study, drinking 350 milliliters of pineapple juice, which is high in bromelain, two times each day before and after surgery helped reduce bruising and promote healing. Similar studies have found comparable results with bromelain, but further investigation is needed to confirm this finding. Bromelain can be ingested in food and drinks, taken as a supplement, or applied as a cream.
Other homeopathic treatments for bruising are in use, though evidence of their effectiveness is anecdotal, and no formal human studies have proven their efficacy. Bella perennis has been suggested for bruising that does not respond to treatment with Arnica. Ledum palustre is often used to treat bruising around the eyes. Phosphorus, Sulphuricum acidum, aloe vera, 1 percent vitamin K cream with retinol, and comfrey cream have also been suggested as homeopathic treatments for bruising.
Bibliography
"Arnica." Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, www.mountsinai.org/health-library/herb/arnica. Accessed 20 Sept. 2024.
Berry, Jennifer. "A List of Ways to Get Rid of a Bruise." Medical News Today, 20 Feb. 2024, www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/320090. Accessed 20 Sept. 2024.
“Bruising (Homeopathy) – Health Information Library.” PeaceHealth, Dec. 2023, www.peacehealth.org/medical-topics/id/hn-2203005. Accessed 21 Aug. 2023.
Luo, Elaine K., and Emily Cronkleton. “How to Get Rid of Bruises: 10 Remedies.” Healthline, 9 Jan. 2024, www.healthline.com/health/how-to-get-rid-of-bruises. Accessed 20 Sept. 2024.
Ramelet, A. A., et al. “Homeopathic Arnica in Postoperative Haematomas.” Dermatology 201 (2000): 347-348.
Raza, Asia. "Clinical Efficacy Of Homeopathic Remedy 'Arnica Montana': A Systematic Review." International Journal of Homeopathy, Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2 Mar. 2021, www.ijhcam.org/index.php/ijhcam/article/view/28. Accessed 20 Sept. 2024.
Seeley, B. M., et al. “Effect of Homeopathic Arnica montana on Bruising in Face-Lifts.” Archives of Facial Plastic Surgery 8 (2006): 54-59.
Stevinson, C., et al. “Homeopathic Arnica for Prevention of Pain and Bruising.” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 96 (2003): 60-65.