Iatrogenic disorders

ANATOMY OR SYSTEM AFFECTED: All

DEFINITION: Health problems caused by medical treatments

CAUSES: Inherent medical risk, misdiagnosis, physician malpractice, medication error, surgical error

SYMPTOMS: Wide ranging

DURATION: Varies from acute to fatal

TREATMENTS: Depends on circumstances

Causes and Symptoms

Iatrogenic disorders may be attributable to inefficient or uncaring physicians or to the risks inherent in medical procedures that are necessary to prevent death or crippling disease. Such disorders are usually divided into those caused by medications, surgery, and medical misdiagnosis.

The average patient of any age expects physicians and the medical infrastructure to deliver perfect cures for all diseases. This is not possible because some diseases have no cure and because medical treatment always involves some potential risk to the persons being treated. In fact, a percentage—usually a small one—of the patients treated for any disease develop unexpected health problems (adverse reactions) that can be diseases themselves.

The term “iatrogenic disorder” is a catchall used to encompass the many different adverse reactions that accompany the practice of modern medicine. The number of such problems has grown as medical science has become more sophisticated. They are often blamed entirely on physicians and other medical staff involved in cases producing disorders.

This blame is correctly directed in instances where a physician and other staff involved are uncaring, inattentive, careless, or incompletely educated. However, iatrogenic disorders often result from the nature of modern medicine. Doctors frequently attempt therapeutic methods (such as surgery) that are innovative efforts that cure serious diseases but have some inherent risk of failure. They may also use therapeutic drugs that are powerful agents for cure of specific disease processes but that have side effects causing other health problems in some people who take them. In addition, doctors will often utilize complicated overall therapy having adverse consequences that patients may not acknowledge despite physicians’ attempts to explain them orally and with consent forms.

Treatment and Therapy

Despite careful efforts of most physicians—who are informed, caring, and efficient—iatrogenic disorders accompany many medical procedures. However, public attention is focused most on the effects of therapeutic agents, drugs and vaccines, because patients are often unaware that no therapeutic agent in use is ever perfectly safe. Even a clear physician description of the dos and don’ts associated with such therapy may be flawed by biological variation among patients, causing problems in one individual but not others. Furthermore, the explosion of new diseases and new versions of old diseases since the late 1980s has led to much more complex treatment regimens. Consequently, iatrogenic disorders occur much more often.

The increase in iatrogenic disorders has become particularly germane in treatment of the aged, patients, and the very young. Hence, several rules must be followed concerning therapeutic agents. First, wherever possible, these medications should be used only after other means fail and the benefits to be gained clearly outweigh the risks entailed. Second, therapy should begin with the lowest possible effective dose, and all dose increases should be accompanied by frequent symptom relief and toxicity monitoring. Third, patients and responsible family members must be made aware of all possible adverse symptoms, how to best counter them, and the foods or other medications to be avoided to diminish iatrogenic potential. Such problems, in the aged, are due to biochemical changes that alter their tolerance for many medications.

Many iatrogenic disorders are caused by the presence of bacterial contamination in and the fact that surgical maintenance of sterility is not absolutely perfect. For example, iatrogenesis occurs after 30 percent of surgical procedures carried out at heavily contaminated surgical sites (such as emergency surgery of abdominal wounds). In addition, the use of antibiotics can be problematic. In many cases, the large doses of these therapeutic agents required to fight primary bacterial infection will cause by other microbes, such as fungi. Furthermore, wide use in hospitals has led to the creation of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

For these reasons, treatment of surgical sites requires individualized attention. Clean wounds can be closed up immediately without high risk of infection, but deep wounds known to be contaminated prior to surgery are often best handled by closing up interior tissues and leaving skin and tissues open until it is clear that infection is under control. Many patients are frightened by such procedures and the pain involved, not understanding that it is in their best interest. Hence, they may resist treatment and accuse conscientious physicians of causing iatrogenic disorders. Such treatment is most crucial in the aged and in young children. In elderly patients the cause is diminution of body defenses against infection (for example, the immune system). It has been reported that the elderly experience a doubled or tripled chance of experiencing complications that may be seen as iatrogenic by their families. Young children are also more at risk than postpubertal individuals and “younger” adults, for reasons related to their incompletely developed immune systems.

Iatrogenesis resulting from misdiagnosis is too complicated an issue to be considered in depth here. In some cases, it is caused by physician inadequacy, but more often such problems are attributable to the great difficulty in diagnosing any disease absolutely.

It is essential for patients and physicians to communicate effectively. Such interaction lowers the occurrence of iatrogenic disorders because patients can decide to forgo treatment or to learn how to comply exactly with complex treatment protocols. Patients who do not receive adequate answers to questions posed to physicians should seek treatment elsewhere. Physicians should completely explain potential problems associated with therapeutic procedures by oral communication, informative consent forms, and well-educated counselors.

Because of the many iatrogenic disorders associated with medical therapy, physicians often believe that the best course of treatment—where a symptom is unclear and severe danger to patients is not imminent—is to allow nature to take its course so as to do no harm. This approach is often misunderstood by patients. To clarify the issue and to satisfy them, it should be explained—by the physician—that treatment can often be more dangerous than a perceived health problem.

It is hoped that the continued development of medical science, careful and complete therapy explanations by medical staffs, and better medical understanding and better treatment compliance by patients will decrease the incidence of iatrogenic disorders.

Bibliography

Apfel, Roberta J., and Susan M. Fisher. To Do No Harm: DES and the Dilemmas of Modern Medicine. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1984.

Camus, Philippe, and Edward C. Rosenow. Drug-Induced and Iatrogenic Respiratory Disease. London: Hodder Arnold, 2010.

Carroll, Paula. Life Wish: One Woman’s Struggle Against Medical Incompetence. Alameda, Calif.: Medical Consumers, 1986.

Farmer, Paul. Infections and Inequalities: The Modern Plagues. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001.

Guibelondo, Dex Marco Tiu. "Iatrogenic Disorders: A Hidden Risk of Medical Treatment." Pharma Features, 24 Feb. 2023, pharmafeatures.com/iatrogenic-disorders-a-hidden-risk-of-medical-treatment/. Accessed 2 Apr. 2024.

Levy, Stuart B. The Antibiotic Paradox: How the Misuse of Antibiotics Destroys Their Curative Powers. 2d ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Perseus, 2002.

Medication Safety Program. "Adverse Drug Events from Specific Medicines." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 10 Apr. 2023, www.cdc.gov/medicationsafety/adverse-drug-events-specific-medicines.html. Web. Accessed 2 Apr. 2024.

Morath, Julianne M., and Joanne E. Turnbull. To Do No Harm: Ensuring Patient Safety in Health Care Organizations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2005.

Preger, Leslie, ed. Iatrogenic Diseases. 2 vols. Boca Raton, Fla.: CRC Press, 1986.

Sharpe, Virginia F., and Alan I. Faden. Medical Harm: Historical, Conceptual, and Ethical Dimensions of Iatrogenic Illness. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998.

Vincent, Charles, Maeve Ennis, and Robert J. Audley, eds. Medical Accidents. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993.

Wilson, Michael, Brian Henderson, and Rod McNab. Bacterial Disease Mechanisms: An Introduction to Cellular Microbiology. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2002.