Ornithopoda
Ornithopoda refers to a group of herbivorous dinosaurs within the Ornithischia clade, characterized by their bird-like hips. This group includes species that are more closely related to Edmontosaurus than to Triceratops and encompasses small Middle Jurassic heterodontosaurids and larger Late Cretaceous euornithopods. Ornithopods were prominent during the Cretaceous period, noted for their distinct features such as crests, duck-bills, and beaks. They varied greatly in size, with some species measuring just 80 cm and others reaching lengths of over 16 meters.
Fossil evidence suggests that ornithopods were primarily bipedal or capable of both bipedal and quadrupedal locomotion, adapting to various environments as they evolved. Their dentition was particularly advanced, allowing them to chew and grind food, which was beneficial for exploiting the diverse plant life available during their time. They are classified into several families, including the well-known hadrosaurs, which were widespread in North America and other regions. While ornithopods were not as intelligent as some carnivorous dinosaurs, they likely relied on herd behavior for defense against predators. Recent paleontological findings continue to shed light on their evolutionary history and ecological adaptations, highlighting their importance in prehistoric ecosystems.
Ornithopoda
Introduction
Ornithopoda is defined as all Cerapoda species more closely related to Edmontosaurus than to Triceratops and is comprised of the small Middle Jurassic heterodontosaurids and the Middle Jurassic to Late Cretaceous euornithopods. The unarmored herbivorous ornithopods were the most prosperous of Ornithischia (bird-hipped) dinosaurs, and were noted for their crests, duck-bills, and beaks.
Ornithopods reached their peak in terms of abundance and diversity in the Cretaceous period. Although the first small bipedal basal forms appeared in the fossil record during the Middle Jurassic, later species evolved into very large forms, which were particularly successful across the North American continent.
Fast Facts
Pronunciation: The term Ornithopoda (or-ni-THOP-o-da) was first introduced by Othniel Charles Marsh in 1881 and means “bird-foot.”
Time Period: Middle Jurassic (176 million years ago) to Late Cretaceous (66 million years ago)
Size: 80 cm to16.5 m (3–55 ft) in length
Weight: 30 kg to 23 tons (66 –50,700 lb)
Diet: Herbivorous
Location: Worldwide
Lifespan: 30 years of age or more
Homologous Traits
All dinosaurs are defined as either bird-hipped ornithischians or lizard-hipped saurischians. Ornithopods are a subgroup of Ornithischia, and therefore share all those traits that define dinosaurs, which include upright posture, modified fourth and fifth digits on the hands, three-toed feet, specialized crests on the humerus and tibia bones, and a femur with a ball-like head at one end, as well as all those traits that define the Ornithischia such as a backwards pointing pubis and ischium, an unpaired predentary bone at the lower jaw, a toothless snout, a narrow palpebral “eyelid” bone, leaf-shaped cheek teeth, at least five sacral vertebrae, and hardened tendons above the pelvis area to stiffen the backbone.
Ornithopods were unarmored bipedal or both bipedal and quadrupedal herbivorous dinosaurs. Homologous traits include a lack of armor, an elongated pubis bone, and no hole in the bone of the outer lower jaw. Many ornithopod skulls also display obvious herbivorous adaptations, such as strong and closely packed teeth with extensive wear and depressed jaw joints.
Ornithopods are classified into the heterodontodaurids, iguanodontids, and hadrosaurids, with the traditional fourth group (the hypsilophodontids) now dissolved. The abundant Iguanodontia species evolved particularly enlarged nostrils but had lost the premaxillary teeth. The hadrosaurs possessed flattened premaxillae and maxillae, which were responsible for their wide duck-like bills. Hadrosaurs also possessed many rows of very closely packed cheek teeth. Such dentition was well adapted to their advanced and effective feeding system in which they ground their food. The apparent adaptation of ornithopod jaws for grinding and ceratopsian jaws for slicing is one of the most notable differences between these two types of ornithischian dinosaurs. Researchers believe that such differences relate to reducing resource competition through different feeding mechanisms and food processing.
Evolutionary Divergences
Early basal forms of ornithopods were likely descended from a common Asian ancestor from before the Jurassic period. The evolutionary split between heterodontosaurids and euornithopods occurred relatively quickly and certainly by the Middle Jurassic, with species dispersing from Asia to Africa, to North America in the Late Jurassic, Europe at the start of the Cretaceous, and finally into South America during the Late Cretaceous. While early ornithopods appeared to have lived in relatively harsh environments, the later euornithopods have been found in a diverse range of habitats, from deltas to broad, river-rich plains.
Perhaps one of the greatest evolutionary adaptations of ornithopods was the development of ever more complex dentition. The densely packed teeth seen in the ceratopsians and hadrosaurs, together with their relatively sophisticated digestive systems, allowed many ornithopod species to benefit from varied plant life. Compared with the saurischian herbivores (the sauropods), the development of a specialized dentition made it possible for ornithischian herbivores to grind and chew their food. This is considered unique among dinosaurs, in fact among all other reptiles, and was traditionally thought to be a specific mammalian trait. Although the method used by ornithopods to chew their food differed from that of mammals, the possession of a rotating lower jaw (as seen in heterodontosaurs) and rotating maxilla (as seen in later ornithopods) made this food processing ability possible. Chewing food may seem commonplace, but it was rare among dinosaurs. The ability of ornithopods to chew their food likely explains their significant success during the Cretaceous period, allowing them to utilize the increasingly diverse vegetation as the previously abundant and highly successful sauropods began to decline.
Creatures in This Group
Ornithopods shared a common ancestor with the other ornithischian subgroups, Thyreophora and Cerapoda (Marginocephalia). The common ancestral link between the thyreophorans, marginocephalians (pachycephalosaurs and ceratopsians), and ornithopods means that species from these divisions are grouped together in the node-based Genasauria clade.
Ornithopoda is a stem-based clade consisting of the small Middle Jurassic Heterodontosauridae and the Middle Jurassic to Late Cretaceous Euornithopoda branches. Traditional classification of Euornithopoda separated it into two monophyletic subgroups, the Hypsilophodontidae and the Iguanodontia; however, recent research has clarified that Hypsilophodontidae is a polyphyletic group and consequently all these species are now placed within other clades.
Heterodontodaurids were the smallest and most basal ornithischians and were noted for a horny beak and a row of tightly-packed teeth. The paraphyletic iguanodontids include a range of species that began to acquire relatively advanced hadrosaursian-like traits. Well known species include Iguanodon from Europe and Ouranosaurus from North Africa, both of which roamed the landscape during the Early Cretaceous, as well as the Late Jurassic Camptosaurus from North America, Middle Jurassic Callovosaurus from England, various Iguanodon species, and the hadrosaurids. Among the best known and most diverse of ornithopod clades were the duck-billed hadrosaurs from the Late Cretaceous, such as Hadrosaurus, Edmontosaurus, Saurolophus, and Parasaurolophus. Hadrosaurs were particularly successful across the North American continent, as well as in Central Asia and China.
Ecology
The hadrosaurian snouts and nasal crests are thought to relate to improved vocal communication, in which the hollow crests were used to amplify and resonate sound over long distances. These crests may also have been related to sexual display and identification or as an indication of age. Certainly, the enlarged nares would have provided these species with a very good sense of smell, a useful tool in avoiding predations and in finding food. Generally speaking, herbivorous dinosaurs were less intelligent than predators. Ornithopods were not as intelligent as the carnivorous theropods, based on body to brain ratio measures (encephalization quotient), but were more intelligent than arkylosaur and stegosaur ornithischians as well as the saurischian sauropods.
As with extant species today, herbivorous dinosaurs evolved ways in which to defend themselves or to avoid predation. Ornithopods were not as fast as the carnivorous theropods, and they did not possess the famous body armor seen in the thyreophoran species. Many paleontologists believe that ornithopodan defense relied on safety in numbers, with many species living in large non-segregated herds, as well as having better running stability and maneuverability than the faster theropods. Ornithopod feeding behavior is relatively well understood compared to other herbivorous species due to intact fossilized stomach contents. In particular, paleontologists have found that hadrosaurs consumed a diet of plant parts that included conifer needles and twigs, which suggests hadrosaurs were active terrestrial browsers that feed on trees, as well as low-lying vegetation. Researchers believe that all ornithopods were active foragers and able to chew their food.
Paleontology News
The term Ornithopoda (bird-foot) was first introduced by Othniel Charles Marsh in 1881 to specifically classify bipedal herbivorous dinosaurs that lacked body armor. Ornithopoda was first introduced by Marsh during the infamous Bone Wars with Edward Drinker Cope. Early literature references referred to ornithopods as bipedal ornithischian dinosaurs. Later research highlighted that all dinosaurs (i.e., ornithischian and saurischian together) likely descended from a basal bipedal reptile and therefore bipedalism is now considered an ancestral trait for all dinosaurs.
Although ornithopods are considered the most important group of ornithischians during the Cretaceous, current understanding of the phylogeny, evolutionary relationships, and cladistic definitions remains unresolved due to a lack of complete descriptions of basal species anatomy. Many paleontologists state that the instability in the position and content of Ornithopoda demonstrates that further ornithischian research is required to explain its current phylogeny and phylogenetic definitions. However, recent discoveries of basal species such as Changchunsaurus parvus and Jeholosaurus shangyuanensis in China have helped clarify sister-group relationships within early ornithopod forms.
A study published in 2024 focused on tooth formation time, tooth replacement rates, and daily tooth wear rates of ornithopoda over time. The study found that as ornithopods evolved, their tooth crown volume increased as did their body sizes. Hadrosaurids, for example, experienced significant growth due to more compact dental batteries and accelerated tooth replacement rates. These findings suggested dietary shifts from more nutritious plant parts to less nutritious, fibrous materials, which indicates ornithopod’s evolving ecological role throughout their history.
Bibliography
Brusatte, Stephen L., et al. “The Origin and Early Radiation of Dinosaurs.” Earth-Science Reviews, vol. 101, no. 1–2, 2010, pp. 68–100. ScienceDirect, doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2010.04.001.
Butler, Richard J., et al. “The Phylogeny of the Ornithischian Dinosaurs.” Journal of Systematic Palaeontology, vol. 6, no. 1, 2008, pp. 1–40. Taylor & Francis, doi.org/10.1017/S1477201907002271.
Fastovsky, David E., and David B. Weishampel. Dinosaurs: A Concise Natural History. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009.
Langer, Max C., et al. “The Origin and Early Evolution of Dinosaurs.”Biological Review, vol. 85, no. 1, 2010, pp. 55–110. Wiley Online Library, dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-185X.2009.00094.x.
Lucas, Spencer George. Dinosaurs: The Textbook. McGraw-Hill, 2004.
Madzia, Daniel, et al. "Osteology, Phylogenetic Affinities and Taxonomic Status of the Enigmatic Late Maastrichtian Ornithopod Taxon Orthomerus Dolloi (Dinosauria, Ornithischia)." Cretaceous Research, vol. 108, 2020. ScienceDirect, doi.org/10.1016/j.cretres.2019.104334. Accessed 5 Oct. 2024.
Martin, Anthony J. Introduction to the Study of Dinosaurs. Blackwell, 2006.
Nesbitt, Sterling J. “The Early Evolution of Archosaurs: Relationships and the Origin of Major Clades.” Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 352 (2011): 1–292.
Ősi, Attila, et al. "Trophic Evolution in Ornithopod Dinosaurs Revealed by Dental Wear." Nature Communications, vol. 15, no. 1, 2024, pp. 1-12. Nature, doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-51697-9. Accessed 5 Oct. 2024.
Parker, Steve. Dinosaurus: The Complete Guide to Dinosaurs. Firefly Books, 2009.
Sereno, P. C. “Basal Archosaurs: Phylogenetic Relationships and Functional Implications.”Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, vol. 11, no. S4, 1991, pp. 1–53. Taylor & Francis, dx.doi.org/10.1080/02724634.1991.10011426.
Weishampel, David B., et al. Dinosauria. University of California Press, 2007.