Positive feedback and tipping points
Positive feedback and tipping points are critical concepts in understanding climate change dynamics. Positive feedback refers to a self-reinforcing process where an initial change leads to further changes in the same direction. For instance, in the Arctic, rising temperatures cause ice to melt, exposing darker ocean water that absorbs more heat, which in turn leads to more ice melting—a cycle that amplifies the warming effect. Tipping points, on the other hand, signify moments when a system transitions from one stable state to another, often abruptly and irreversibly. An example can be found in the melting of the Greenland ice sheet, which, if temperatures continue to rise, may reach a tipping point where it melts faster than it can reform during colder seasons. While these phenomena illustrate the complex interplay of climate systems, they also highlight the challenges in predicting long-term climate behavior due to their non-linear and interdependent nature. Understanding these concepts is essential for grasping the potential consequences of climate change and the urgent need for mitigation strategies.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Positive feedback and tipping points
Definitions: Positive feedback is a process in which some ongoing change in a system amplifies itself; tipping points are rapid transitions from one stable state in a system to another stable state
Positive feedback can exacerbate the effects of small changes in climate and force a major climate system to a tipping point beyond which it alters quickly and unpredictably.
The term “tipping point” is often used loosely for several types of rapid change in climate. Scientists, however, restrict the usage to two related effects in a rapidly evolving system. “Positive feedback,” by contrast, has a generally accepted, specific usage: It refers to a self-amplifying effect. When in the1990’s scientists found evidence that regional and global climates were altering because of pollution, some worried that change would come not gradually but unpredictably, perhaps suddenly. The concepts of positive feedback and tipping points are used to explain some aspects of sudden change. They also exemplify the complexity of cause and effect in climate.
The term “feedback” in general refers to a direct relation between the input of a process and its output. The idea comes from electronics. Amplifiers in particular can be made to reduce (negative feedback) or increase (positive feedback) amplification by redirecting some part of the output signal back to the input. In climate science the input and output are heat energy. A salient example comes from the Arctic Ocean. The packed ice that has covered it for millennia reflects much more of the sun’s light (and heat energy) than does open water. As Arctic atmospheric temperature rises (the input of the system) from heat retained in the atmosphere because of the greenhouse effect, more and more ice melts (an output of the system), exposing open water. The water absorbs more heat energy than is typical of an icebound ocean, and that heat melts more ice, exposing yet more open water. The process continues until some equilibrium point has been reached among air temperature, water temperature, and ice cover (if any).
A tipping point entails a loss of equilibrium or stability in a system so that it inevitably evolves from one state to another. In a mundane example, a man may trip and begin to fall, and the point at which his balance is irrecoverably lost is the tipping point that takes him from one state (standing) to another (fallen). In some cases a tipping point, once past, removes some essential capacity from the system—a second meaning for the term. If the man is so obese that he no longer can stand up again on his own after he falls, he loses an essential capacity. Climatic tipping points are difficult to calculate, yet climate-determined systems, if sufficiently pressured by external forces, may pass a tipping point and lose stability. By the late twentieth century increasing average air temperatures became a powerful forcing agent. Among many systems affected, the seasonal melting on the ice sheet covering Greenland accelerated. If air temperatures continue to climb, scientists believe, at some point Greenland’s ice will melt faster during summers than it can form during winters. At that tipping point the loss of the ice sheet into the ocean becomes unstoppable, even though it requires centuries to complete. This tipping point, however, would not be a “point of no return.” A new Greenland ice sheet could form if average summer temperatures were to drop low enough.
Bibliography
Flannery, Tim. The Weather Makers: How Man Is Changing the Climate and What It Means for Life on Earth. New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 2005.
Gladwell, Malcolm. The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference. Boston: Back Bay Books, 2002.
Pearce, Fred. With Speed and Violence: Why Scientists Fear Tipping Points in Climate Change. Boston: Beacon Press, 2007.