Debate
Debate is a formal discussion format that involves presenting arguments related to a specific motion or proposition, following established rules. Participants, known as debaters, articulate their positions either in favor of or against the topic at hand, employing public speaking and performance skills to make their case compelling. The essence of debate lies in exploring controversial issues while maintaining respect and avoiding personal attacks or emotional appeals. Various types of debate exist, each with its own structure and rules, such as Congressional debates, Lincoln-Douglas debates, policy debates, and public forum debates.
These formats can range from individual arguments to team competitions, often focusing on current events or significant policy proposals. Debaters are judged not only on the content and clarity of their arguments but also on their style and strategic execution. Overall, debate serves as a platform for critical thinking and engagement with complex topics, fostering an environment where diverse perspectives can be expressed and examined.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Debate
A debate is a formal discussion of a motion or proposition that follows specific rules. Participants use arguments to support their positions, either in favor of or in opposition to the topic. Debating requires public speaking and performance skills, because the participants seek to present a solid and well-received case. Debate allows participants and the audience to consider controversial topics while avoiding personal attacks, insults, and unsupported emotional appeals. While political debates are common, many individuals compete in structured tournaments.
Overview
The goal of most debate is to thoroughly explore a motion or resolution, which is a formal statement, idea, or policy. Many motions address a policy that would change the present circumstances, while others are statements about which participants argue truth or falsehood. For example, a resolution might state, "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex." The side in favor, the proposition, presents arguments to support this statement, while the opposition presents arguments against it. Each side seeks to make its position understood.
Lawmakers usually debate such issues with the intention of persuading others to vote with them, but in competitive debates, a final consensus typically is not required. Instead, competitive debaters are judged on a number of factors, including content (arguments and examples), style (such as voice), and strategy (including structure of argument and responses to arguments).
Debate Events
Many types of debate exist. Events follow approved formats and specific rules, including time limits.
Congressional debates are much like US legislative sessions. Students present bills and resolutions, argue in turn for and against them, and vote on the bills. One student is elected the presiding officer.
Extemporaneous debate consists of one-on-one arguments on a topic. Participants learn the topic and are told whether to present pro or con arguments. They typically have thirty minutes to prepare for the debate.
Lincoln-Douglas is a one-on-one debate that emphasizes a moral perspective and philosophical approach. Each participant researches the approved topic in advance and must form arguments for both sides. Debaters are notified at the event whether to argue the proposition or opposition. The debate lasts about forty-five minutes and includes prepared speeches, quickly constructed rebuttals, and cross examination.
Policy debates take place between two teams of two debaters. The question generally involves a proposed policy plan. The affirmative team argues for the policy, while the opposing team argues to reject it. Policy debates include speeches and cross examination.
Public forum is a two-on-two debate on a current event. The winner of a coin toss chooses to argue pro or con or chooses to speak first or second. Participants explain their cases, rebut and refute, and participate in a crossfire, which involves asking questions of the opposing team.
World schools debate combines prepared topics with impromptu topics. The focus of this three-on-three format is on issues rather than procedure and debate theory. Members of each side present speeches alternately. The debate concludes with rebuttals on each side. Participants may question one another and respond to questions through most of the debate, but not during the rebuttals.
Bibliography
"Competition Events." National Speech & Debate Association, www.speechanddebate.org/competition-events/. Accessed 31 Dec. 2024.
“History.” National Debate Tournament, nationaldebatetournament.org/history/. Accessed 31 Dec. 2024.
“What is Debate?” American Debate League, www.americandebateleague.org/what-is-debate.html#/. Accessed 31 Dec. 2024.
“What is Debating? The ESU’s Complete Guide to the History and Development of Debating.” English Speaking Union, 12 July 2022, www.esu.org/news-and-views/what-is-debating-history-developments-relevancy/. Accessed 31 Dec. 2024.