Garden city movement
The Garden City Movement is an influential urban planning concept that seeks to merge the benefits of urban and rural living by creating self-sustaining communities. Initiated by Ebenezer Howard in the early 20th century, the movement arose as a response to the overcrowded and polluted conditions of rapidly industrializing cities. Howard envisioned towns organized in concentric circles, with a central park surrounded by civic buildings, commercial areas, and residential zones, all designed to facilitate community interaction and maintain green spaces.
The movement also aimed to incorporate principles of collective land ownership, proposing that community members would manage their resources collectively rather than relying on private landlords. While the ideal of a fully realized garden city proved financially and operationally challenging, it led to the establishment of notable planned communities such as Letchworth and Welwyn Garden City in the UK and inspired similar developments worldwide, including in the United States and Australia.
Despite its criticisms for being overly rigid and nostalgically idealized, the Garden City Movement's core principles continue to influence contemporary urban planning. Today, urban planners are revisiting its concepts to promote sustainable, walkable communities that integrate green infrastructure, aligning with modern goals of environmental responsibility and community well-being.
Garden city movement
The garden city movement is an urban planning concept that melds together aspects of both city and country environments. The idea was born from an idealized desire to create self-sustaining towns of limited development that were planned around a pattern of concentric circles. It gained popularity at the start of the twentieth century as a welcome contrast to the often heavily polluted and congested cities that arose in the wake of the Industrial Revolution.
These cities were intended to be more than just models of urban planning. They were also meant to incorporate socialist principles of collective land ownership in which all management decisions are governed by the public community rather than private interests. However, the garden city as originally conceived was too impractical to be financially viable or operationally functional. Nonetheless, many of the philosophies and innovations underlying the movement proved to be highly influential in the development of planned communities around the world.
Brief History
The father of the garden city movement was Ebenezer Howard. Howard was a stenographer for the British Parliament by trade, and he lacked any formal training in urban planning, architecture, engineering, or landscaping. However, in his free time, he toyed with new ideas for city planning that culminated in the release of To-morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform (1898), which was re-released in 1902 as Garden Cities of To-morrow.
He envisioned a series of compact, self-sustainable communities that would be surrounded by tracts of greenbelt, which is a city planning concept in which natural lands are prevented from being developed to preserve them as wild spaces. The idea was to combine the advantages of city living with the relative solitude of the countryside. In addition, Howard pictured garden cities as relying upon philosophies that stretched beyond simple city planning. He wished to incorporate socialist-derived protections for its residents that would enable them to maintain the public control of all assets. Thus founded, the garden city would operate as a collective in which all rent would be paid to a central corporation jointly owned by the community's residents. These funds would in turn be spent on civic improvements rather than funneled to investors or landlords with no active emotional investment in the well-being of the community.
Howard's plans required large tracts of undeveloped agricultural land and financial assets well beyond his means. To fund his vision, he required investors, whose involvement necessitated concessions to his original plans. He was forced to abandon his vision of a central collective in favor of more traditional landlords and rents. He also clashed heavily with the architects hired to build the first garden city. Despite these hurdles, Letchworth, the first garden city, was begun in 1903 about thirty miles outside London. A second community called Welwyn Garden City, which was more closely modeled on Howard's original idea, was founded in 1920.
Garden City Model
Howard's original conception of his idealized garden city was intended to be a small city of roughly thirty thousand people living together in a compact space of one thousand acres. This land upon which the city would be built would be located well outside the sphere of any large urban center. He believed that creating a distance between large industrial cities and his garden cities would be less expensive on which to build while maintaining a rustic lifestyle. When any garden city began to exceed its intended occupancy, a new garden city was to be constructed nearby, like another wing of a larger planned community.
Howard's physical city model envisioned a city plan using a sequence of circles, with each ring devoted to a different aspect of public use. He proposed building cities around a five-acre garden that would serve as a community focal point. It would also serve as a natural space in the heart of the community. Howard's original concept encircled the park with the key buildings of civic life, including governmental offices and hospitals, as well as cultural centers such as museums, amphitheaters, and libraries. These buildings were to be located on the inner ring of an even larger central park. Around this mix of municipal and cultural development, Howard imagined a commercial center of shops with pedestrian walkways. The next few rings would be devoted to a mix of housing, schools, and churches. The outer halo of the garden city would be composed of manufacturing centers such as factories that were to emphasize worker equality. Encircling the entire development would be the farms that would provide the necessities required by the town. As the city was built in the shape of a giant circle, he pictured six wide picturesque avenues cutting through the city like spokes, with smaller roads connecting the city's neighborhoods. From center to edge, the radius of the city was to be no more than three-quarters of a mile, allowing for easy commutes and a heightened sense of community. Each home was to be affordable for a blue-collar citizen. Howard also encouraged the construction of residential gardens.
Howard's ideas have drawn criticism. Principally among them, urban planners have suggested that his plans were too rigid and relied upon faded nostalgic visions of England's rural past. As such, they have been perceived as a backward-looking idealization of pre-Industrial Revolution England. Further, Howard's strict city plans allowed for little deviation, lending to a feeling of sameness between different neighborhoods and the cities themselves. As a result, some critics have argued that the resulting cities lacked the mixed-use and vitality of cities. Additionally, critics have suggested that the dense city center and central park functioned more as a barrier between sections of the town than a unifying element.
Topic Today
The garden city movement inspired a number of planned communities around the world, particularly those that incorporated green spaces within residential communities. In the United States, the Russell Sage Foundation created the communities of Sunnyside Gardens and Forest Hills Gardens in the Queens borough of New York City in 1910 based upon Howard's principles. Such communities typically were based more on Howard's incorporation of green spaces, lower population densities, and personal gardens. Larger cities such as Canberra, Australia; Christchurch, New Zealand; and New Delhi, India, used the concepts of the garden city movement during their initial planning. The greenbelt movement and New Towns Act were strongly influenced by the earlier garden city movement.
As a model for planning, the green city framework remains relevant but in a more flexible application. Because of the importance of sustainability and responsible urban planning in the twenty-first century amid climate change, some urban planners have revisited the principles of the garden city. Howard's idealized concept may help create walkable communities and green infrastructure. Howard's ideas were utilized in the development of communities such as Poundbury and Ebbsfleet in England, and the American community of Celebration, Florida.
Bibliography
Goldfield, David R. "The Neighborhood Unit Plan." Neighborhood and Community Environments, edited by Irwin Altman and Abraham Wandersman, Springer Science and Business Media, 2013, pp. 231–36.
Grant, Jill L. "Garden City Movement." Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research, edited by Alex C. Michalos, Springer Netherlands, 2014, pp. 2394–96.
Hall, Peter. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design since 1880. 4th ed., Wiley-Blackwell, 2014.
Hall, Peter, and Colin Ward. Sociable Cities: The 21st-Century Reinvention of the Garden City. 2nd ed., Routledge, 2014.
Hardy, Dennis. Utopian England: Community Experiments 1900–1945. Routledge, 2000.
Howard, Ebenezer. "Garden Cities of To-morrow." Cornell University, urbanplanning.library.cornell.edu/DOCS/howard.htm. Accessed 10 Dec. 2024.
Meacham, Standish. Regaining Paradise: Englishness and the Early Garden City Movement. Yale UP, 1999.
Moreira, Susanna. "What Are Garden Cities?" Arch Daily, 12 May 2021, www.archdaily.com/961275/what-are-garden-cities. Accessed 10 Dec. 2024.
Ross, Philip, and Yves Cabannes. 21st Century Garden Cities of To-morrow: A Manifesto. Lulu, 2014.
Wainwright, Oliver. "The Garden City Movement: From Ebenezer to Ebbsfleet." Guardian, 17 Mar. 2014, www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/architecture-design-blog/2014/mar/17/ebbsfleet-garden-city-george-osborne. Accessed 10 Dec. 2024.
"What Is a Garden City?" International Garden Cities Exhibition, www.garden-cities-exhibition.com/what-is-a-garden-city. Accessed 10 Dec. 2024.