East–West Schism
The East–West Schism refers to the significant theological and political divide that emerged between the Roman Catholic Church in the West and the Eastern Orthodox Church in the East during the medieval period, culminating in 1054. This schism arose from a complex interplay of factors, including a power struggle between Rome and Constantinople, and deep-seated theological disagreements that could not be reconciled. Key issues included differing views on purgatory and the origin of the Holy Spirit, as well as contrasting governance structures; the East operated as a theocracy with the Byzantine emperor holding authority over church and state, while the West maintained a separation of powers between spiritual and temporal leaders.
The official split was marked by mutual excommunication between Pope Leo IX and Patriarch Michael I Cerularius, which underscored the enduring nature of their division. The sacking of Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade in 1204 further exacerbated tensions, demonstrating a lasting rift that subsequent councils were unable to heal. In recent decades, however, efforts for reconciliation have emerged, most notably in 1965 when mutual excommunications were reversed. Today, both churches face the challenge of remaining relevant in a secularizing world, prompting discussions on whether to pursue unity or to navigate their coexistence as distinct entities.
East–West Schism
The East-West schism was a theological rift that developed during the medieval period and eventually resulted in the division of the Christian church into the Roman Catholic Church of the West and the Eastern Orthodox Church of the East. This rift was the result of many different factors. On one level, it was a political power struggle between the cities of Rome and Constantinople; on another level, it was driven by fundamental theological differences that many felt could not be reconciled and thus had to exist in separate spheres. Still others contend that the schism was inevitable due to the cultural differences at work. Language also played an important, if often overlooked, role in the division; in the East, the predominant language was Greek, while in the West, Latin became the preferred tongue for civil and ecclesiastical communication and record keeping.
Background
The origins of the competition between the great cities of Rome and Constantinople can be traced back at least as far as the year 330 CE. Prior to that time, Rome had been the capital of the Roman Empire, the seat of power that held dominion over a vast realm. In 326, however, the Roman emperor Constantine the Great (272–337 CE) relocated the capital to the city of Byzantium.
The new capital was dedicated in 330 as Constantinople and quickly replaced Rome as the center of political and economic influence, which in turn meant greater influence for those members of the church hierarchy who called Constantinople their home. Clerics in Rome began to fear that greater influence for their counterparts to the east would mean a less significant role for them, and thus was born a rivalry that would smolder for centuries before finally erupting.
Overview
Many of the theological disputes that helped fuel the East-West schism may seem trivial by modern standards, but because life during ancient and medieval times was so brutal and unpredictable, even minute details about the spiritual world and the afterlife took on great importance in people’s everyday lives. For example, one point of contention between the East and West concerned the nature and purpose of purgatory. Both Eastern and Western religious thinkers agreed that after death, the soul required further perfecting before it would be ready to enter the heavenly realm. But how to characterize this experience of cleansing was a very different matter. For the Eastern church, purgatory was conceived of as a kind of refining preparation for a closer approach to the divine; in the West, purgatory was seen as a miserable state of torment only slightly less degrading than hell itself.
Also playing a major role in the East-West division was the filioque controversy, which was a disagreement about the origin of the Holy Spirit in Christian teachings. Was the Holy Spirit sent by God the Father or by both the Father and the Son? The East believed the former, while in the West the latter view won out.
Another significant difference between the two spheres was that the East was a theocracy, with the Byzantine emperor as the supreme authority in matters of both church and state. The West, by contrast, vested temporal and spiritual power in different individuals, though often enough these might work together toward common goals.
The year 1054 is cited as the official date of the schism. At issue was, and had been for centuries, whether the pope in Rome was the supreme leader of the Christian church, a Western doctrine known as “papal primacy.” This was rejected in the East, where the leader of the church was considered to be the ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople, known as the primus inter pares, or “first among equals.” In 1054, the long-simmering debate culminated in mutual excommunication between Patriarch Michael I Cerularius (1000–1059) and Pope Leo IX (1002–54), who cast each other (and the masses of their faithful) out of their respective churches. Such actions were not unprecedented, but these excommunications proved to be lasting.
On Good Friday of 1204, crusaders pillaging their way eastward to wrest the Holy Land from Muslim control reached Constantinople, and in a drunken frenzy, they sacked the city. This outraged followers of the Eastern church and made clear that the schism was not only still alive and well but unlikely to be ameliorated. Indeed, the two Councils of Lyon, in 1245 and 1272–74, and the Councils of Basel (1431–49) and Florence (1438–45) failed to bring about reconciliation.
Only within the twentieth and twenty-first centuries have efforts to heal the rift between East and West and bring the two sides closer together met with any success. On December 7, 1965, Pope Paul VI (1897–1978) and Patriarch Athenagoras I (1886–1972) finally acknowledged the misdeeds committed by all parties and reversed the mutual excommunications at special simultaneous meetings in Rome and Istanbul (formerly Constantinople). In 2001 Pope John Paul II (1920–2005) issued an apology for the wrongs committed by Catholics against Constantinople and its Orthodox faithful in the Fourth Crusade. When John Paul II died in 2005, Patriarch Bartholomew I (b. 1940) attended his funeral, an act that was widely interpreted as another step bringing East and West closer together.
The two churches, Catholic and Orthodox, find themselves at a bewildering crossroads as they struggle to remain relevant in an increasingly secular world. One school of thought suggests that they should continue to work toward reconciliation, with an eye toward combining their resources and promoting the best each has to offer. Another viewpoint is that with religious participation declining with each successive generation, the two halves of the Christian church will instead find themselves struggling to survive and competing with one another.
Bibliography
Becker, Karl J, and Ilaria Morali, eds. Catholic Engagement with World Religions: A Comprehensive Study. Maryknoll: Orbis, 2010. Print.
Blainey, Geoffrey. A Short History of Christianity. Lanham: Rowman, 2014. Print.
Ferry, Luc. A Brief History of Thought: A Philosophical Guide to Living. Trans. Theo Cuffe. New York: Harper, 2011. Print.
Hashmi, Sohail H., ed. Just Wars, Holy Wars, & Jihads: Christian, Jewish, and Muslim Encounters and Exchanges. New York: Oxford UP, 2012. Print.
Johnson, Eric L, ed. Psychology & Christianity: Five Views. 2nd ed. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2010. Print.
Lynch, Joseph H. Early Christianity: A Brief History. New York: Oxford UP, 2010. Print.
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years. New York: Viking, 2010. Print.
North, John A., and S. R. F. Price, eds. The Religious History of the Roman Empire: Pagans, Jews, and Christians. New York: Oxford UP, 2011. Print.
Phan, Peter C., ed. Christianities in Asia. Malden: Wiley, 2011. Print.
Wilken, Robert Louis. The First Thousand Years: A Global History of Christianity. New Haven: Yale UP, 2012. Print.