James Hannay
James Hannay was a Scottish author and journalist born on February 17, 1827, in Dumfries, Scotland. His early life included a five-year stint in the Royal Navy, which ended in disgrace due to a court-martial for misconduct. This experience influenced much of his later writing, particularly his novels and short fiction that often reflect themes of adventure and disillusionment. After leaving the Navy, he transitioned to journalism, gaining prominence for his contributions to various publications, such as the London Morning Chronicle and Punch. Hannay also served as a British consul in Barcelona, Spain, where his letters gained popularity.
He is remembered today as a literary critic and advocate of conservative perspectives, particularly through his works like "Studies on Thackeray" and "Satire and Satirists." In his time, he was also recognized as a novelist, with comparisons drawn to notable figures like Thackeray and Charles Dickens. Hannay’s fiction often features idealistic protagonists facing challenges that reflect his own experiences and the influence of writer Thomas Carlyle. Despite some criticisms of his characters and plots, his major works remain influential in literary discussions.
On this Page
Subject Terms
James Hannay
Writer
- Born: February 17, 1827
- Birthplace: Dumfires, Scotland
- Died: January 9, 1873
- Place of death: Barcelona, Spain
Biography
James Hannay was born at Dumfries, Scotland, on February 17, 1827, into an old Scottish family. At age thirteen, he entered the Royal Navy, serving for five years in the Mediterranean Sea until a court-martial found him guilty of misconduct and “riotous behavior.” He received a discharge “with disgrace” and afterwards went to great effort to have the sentence reversed. He ultimately succeeded, but he had a lifelong disdain for what he considered incompetent bureaucracy. His opinion was influenced both by feelings of family superiority and by the antidemocratic individualism of writer Thomas Carlyle. Hannay would memorialize his navy experience in his novels and short fiction.
After his discharge, Hannay worked as a journalist for the London Morning Chronicle and several publications devoted to humor. By his early twenties he had gained a reputation as an entertaining public lecturer and satirist and was contributing to Punch and several important political journals. In 1855, he became the leading political writer for a new publication, the Illustrated Times.
Two years later, Hannay ran unsuccessfully for Parliament as a conservative from Dumfries. From 1860 to 1868, he wrote first for the Edinburgh Courant and then for the Pall Mall Gazette. In 1868, he was appointed British consul in Barcelona, Spain, serving there until he died on January 9, 1873. Though he considered his consulship a form of exile, his letters “From an Englishman in Spain” to the Pall Mall Gazette were tremendously popular in their time.
In the twenty-first century, Hannay is remembered mainly as an excellent literary critic, a convincing advocate of the conservative philosophical and literary stance. This reputation rests on his Studies on Thackeray, an outstanding early treatment of the work of Victorian author William Makepeace Thackeray; on Essays from “The Quarterly Review”; and on Satire and Satirists: Six Lectures, a discerning and witty appreciation of ancient and contemporary satirists. In his own time, however, some regarded Hannay as a novelist of equal stature with Thackeray, Charles Dickens, and Charlotte Brontë.
Hannay’s sea stories have prompted comparison with Frederick Maryatt. His Royal Navy experience provided the adventures and the premise for his fiction, from brief works such as Biscuits and Grog: Personal Reminiscences and Sketches by Percival Plug, RN to the multivolume novels Singleton Fontenoy, RN and Eustace Conyers: A Novel. Clearly autobiographical, these tales present idealistic youths who experience fascinating adventures but become profoundly disenchanted, eventually triumphing through the traditional values of patrician family ties and intellectual cultivation. Carlyle’s influence is consistently strong; the character Singleton Fontenoy calls him “great in what he teaches, great in what he suggests, greater than all in what he inspires.” Though many of Hannay’s plots are artificial and his characters flat, the two long novels are still considered his finest works.