Naval battle on Lake Champlain during War of 1812
The naval battle on Lake Champlain during the War of 1812 was a pivotal encounter that took place in September 1814, amid broader military efforts related to the conflict. As the British aimed to capture the Lake Champlain Valley for their empire, they assembled a fleet that slightly outmatched the Americans in terms of shipbuilding. However, British Captain George Downie faced challenges in unifying his hastily gathered crew, which ultimately affected their performance in battle.
The key vessels in the confrontation were Downie's thirty-seven-gun ship, Confiance, and the American flagship Saratoga, armed with twenty-six guns. During the battle, Downie was killed, leaving the British fleet without leadership. American Master Commandant Thomas Macdonough skillfully maneuvered his ships, enabling a successful broadside that led to the destruction of the British flagship and significant losses for the British fleet.
The American casualties totaled 52 killed and 58 wounded, while the British suffered 54 dead and 116 wounded, with many taken prisoner. The outcome of this battle was significant, as it prevented the British from gaining naval superiority in the region, ultimately leading to the withdrawal of British ground forces to Canada and influencing the broader peace negotiations that followed the war.
On this Page
Naval battle on Lake Champlain during War of 1812
Type of action: Naval battle in the War of 1812
Date: September 11, 1814
Location: Plattsburgh Bay, New York
Combatants: 937 British vs. 882 Americans
Principal commanders:British, Captain George Downie; American, Master Commandant Thomas Macdonough (1783–1825)
Result: Surrender of the British squadron to the Americans
After the defeat of Napoleon I in early 1814, the British government sent the duke of Wellington’s veterans to Canada and instructed Governor General Sir George Prevost to conquer the Lake Champlain Valley for incorporation into the British empire. British shipbuilding efforts on the lake slightly outmatched those of the Americans. However, the recently arrived Captain George Downie had little time to create unit cohesion among his hastily assembled crews. Master Commandant Thomas Macdonough’s squadron lay anchored with spring lines to each vessel’s anchor cables so each could be turned 180 degrees within its mooring lines. There were four major vessels on each side, and the British had eleven row galleys and gunboats and the Americans ten. The principal combatants were Downie’s thirty-seven-gun Confiance and Macdonough’s twenty-six-gun Saratoga. Downie fell early in the battle, leaving his fleet leaderless. With the outcome in doubt, Macdonough wound his ship so the port guns could be employed, and this fresh broadside allowed him to destroy resistance on the British flagship. Only a few gunboats escaped. Macdonough lost 52 killed and 58 seriously wounded. British casualties included 54 dead, 116 wounded, and the remainder prisoners of war. Also captured were a frigate, a brig, two sloops of war, and several gunboats.
Significance
Because the British lacked naval superiority, Prevost withdrew his ground forces back to Canada. This defeat contributed to the British decision to end the war and restore territory to its prewar status.
Bibliography
Everest, Allan S. The War of 1812 in the Champlain Valley. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press, 1981.
Sweetman, Jack, ed. Great American Naval Battles. Annapolis, Md.: Naval Institute Press, 1998.
Turner, Wesley B. British Generals in the War of 1812: High Command in the Canadas. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1999.