Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI)
The Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI) is a Protestant denomination that traces its roots back to the Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century and the migration of Scottish Presbyterians during the Plantation of Ulster in the seventeenth century. Governed by a system of elders—reflected in the term "presbyter" from Greek—the PCI emphasizes congregational governance over hierarchical leadership. With approximately 225,000 members, it is the second largest Protestant denomination in the Republic of Ireland and primarily located in Northern Ireland, where it ranks just behind the Roman Catholic Church in membership.
Historically, the PCI emerged from Scottish Presbyterianism and faced various challenges, including tensions with the Church of Ireland and internal divisions regarding theological interpretations of the Westminster Confession of Faith. Its core beliefs include the Trinity, the authority of Scripture, and justification by faith, alongside the recognition of two sacraments: baptism and communion. The church practices infant baptism and highlights the faith of parents in this rite.
The PCI is organized into 536 parishes, each overseen by elders and ministers, and holds a general assembly of representatives to address church governance and issues. Recently, the PCI has taken a conservative stance on social issues, notably regarding same-sex relationships, which has influenced its affiliations with other Presbyterian bodies. This context makes the PCI a significant institution within Ireland's religious landscape, embodying a blend of historical tradition and contemporary challenges.
Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI)
The Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI) is a Protestant Christian denomination with its origins in the Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century and the Scottish Presbyterian migration during the Plantation of Ulster during the seventeenth century.
The church's name comes from the word presbyter, the Greek word for elder that refers to the church's governance. During the Reformation, some people opposed the hierarchical form of leadership used by the Roman Catholic Church and the Church of England. Instead, they favored a system in which each church congregation was governed by elders chosen from among its members. These dissenters came to be known as Presbyterians.
The first Presbyterians were largely English Puritans influenced by French theologian John Calvin and one of his pupils, John Knox. Knox, an itinerant preacher who fled to France and then Geneva when the Catholic Mary I came to the throne in England, brought Calvin's Reformed theology to Scotland. He is credited with establishing the Presbyterian denomination and preventing the Church of England from replacing Catholicism as Scotland's national religion during the sixteenth century.
By the mid-2020s, the PCI had around 230,000 members. It remained the second-largest Protestant denomination in the Republic of Ireland after the Church of Ireland, an Anglican church. The majority of its membership is in Northern Ireland, where it is second only to the Roman Catholic Church in membership.
History
The Catholic Irish chieftains in Ireland were problematic for King James I, who ruled England and Ireland and was also known as James VI of Scotland during the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. In a move known as the Plantation of Ulster, English adherents to the Church of England and Scottish Presbyterians were encouraged to relocate to a section of Northern Ireland near 1610. James and other leaders hoped that the Protestant settlers would civilize the Irish chiefs and their followers, who spoke Gaelic and rejected the official church.
Initially, the Presbyterians in Ireland remained part of the Presbyterian Church of Scotland. It was not until 1624 that Scottish army chaplains stationed in Ireland formed the Presbytery of Ulster. Those who followed the Presbyterian way flourished when the Church of England was repressed during the English Civil War (1642–51) and during the subsequent creation of the Commonwealth of England that replaced the monarchy after the war. When Charles II regained the throne in England in 1660, he restored the Church of England as the official church of the country. In 1662, all clergy were required to publicly accept the Act of Uniformity in support of the episcopacy and Book of Common Prayer that were key parts of the Church of England. Those who refused—more than two thousand clergymen—were removed from their positions in what became known as the Great Ejection.
The Act of Uniformity was not enforced in Ireland. During the seventeenth century, the Presbyterians continued to worship with little interference from the government but were still at a disadvantage compared to those who were part of the Church of Ireland, which held the same views and privileges as the Church of England. In the eighteenth century, dissension rose up from within the Presbytery, where conservative members known as Old Lights and liberal New Lights disagreed about the Westminster Confession of Faith, an outline of beliefs drawn up in 1646 by the Westminster Assembly.
Conflict continued into the nineteenth century when some believed that the liberals who rejected the Westminster Confession were followers of Arianism and believed Jesus Christ to be subordinate to God the Father. Eventually, those who were most opposed to the Westminster Confession formed a separate denomination from the PCI, and the Westminster Confession became part of Presbyterian beliefs.
Beliefs
The Westminster Confession of Faith outlines key beliefs of the Presbyterian faith, including belief in the Trinity (God, Jesus Christ, Holy Spirit); the sacrificial death and resurrection of Jesus; biblical scripture as God's inspired word; and justification by faith. Other aspects such as assertions that Roman Catholic worship is idolatry, the pope is the anti-Christ, and a prohibition against marrying non-Christians, are adopted by some and ignored by others.
The PCI recognizes two sacraments: baptism and communion. Communion is available to all who are baptized and in good standing with the church. Infant baptism is performed by sprinkling or pouring of water rather than immersion. Unlike other denominations that see baptism as a rebirth and is related to the child's relationship with God, Irish Presbyterians look to the faith of the parents and the state of their relationship with God. Baptism brings the child into the church community, but the child will later be required to make their own profession of faith to attain full inclusion in the church. Along those lines, the PCI has refused to baptize the children of same-sex couples or allow same-sex couples full membership in the church, viewing homosexuality as incompatible with their faith.
Organization
The PCI consists of 536 parishes organized into presbyteries, or jurisdictions. Elders chosen by the congregation govern each parish and work with ministers to provide oversight and governance to the church. Elders may be men or women, but they must regularly attend services and meet the requirements for voting in the congregation. They must be exemplary in character and set a good example of spiritual and holy behavior. Women are also allowed to be ordained as ministers.
A yearly general assembly of about 1,200 elected representatives from the Presbyterian churches throughout Ireland meets to resolve issues related to the PCI. This group also meets with representatives of Presbyterian churches from other parts of the world, such as Scotland and Wales, as well as with representatives from other denominations, including the Church of Ireland. In 2018, however, because of the more liberal Church of Scotland's and United Reformed Church's positive stances on same-sex marriage, the PCI chose to end its association with their general assemblies. These tensions continued into the 2020s, causing further conflict and resignations.
Bibliography
Beaumont, Gustave de. Ireland: Social, Political, and Religious. Harvard UP, 2007.
Jones, Timothy Paul. Christian History Made Easy. Rose Publishing, 2009.
Liu, Dai. Puritan London: A Study of Religion and Society in the City Parishes. U of Delaware P, 1986.
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years. Viking, 2011.
McGarry, Patsy. "Republic's Secularisation Brings Protestant and Catholic Churches Closer." The Irish Times, 12 June 2018, www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/religion-and-beliefs/republic-s-secularisation-brings-protestant-and-catholic-churches-closer-1.3527014. Accessed 20 Jan 2025.
"Presbyterian Church in Ireland." Ulster Historical Foundation, ulsterhistoricalfoundation.com/presbyterianism/home. Accessed 20 Jan. 2025.
"Presbyterian Church." Irish Council of Churches, www.irishchurches.org/members/presbyterian-church. Accessed 20 Jan. 2025.
"Presbyterianism." British Broadcasting Corporation, www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/plantation/religious/rl02.shtml. Accessed 20 Jan. 2025.
"The Reformation." History Channel. A&E Television Networks, 11 Apr. 2019, www.history.com/topics/religion/reformation. Accessed 20 Jan. 2025.
Ridley, Jasper. The Tudor Age. Carroll & Graf Publishing, 2002.