Wilmot Proviso of 1846

The Wilmot Proviso of 1846

In the decades preceding the Mexican War, which began on May 12, 1846 , Americans began to settle in the vast expanse of Mexican territory that is now Texas, California, and the American southwest. At first the settlers came at the invitation of the Mexican authorities, who were looking to populate the largely empty region, but over time the Mexicans became concerned about the often-rebellious American pioneers and began to clamp down both on immigration and on political dissent. Several incidents between the United States and Mexico, plus the expansionist policies of President James K. Polk, led to the outbreak of war.

The United States achieved victory in the summer of 1847 when it took the Mexican capital of Mexico City, although the formal cessation of hostilities did not take place until February 2, 1848, with the signing of the Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo. Long beforehand, however, there was concern over whether slavery would be permitted in the territory that would inevitably be seized from Mexico. In these pre-Civil War years, there was a precarious political balance between the slave states of the South and the free states of the North. The North, with its larger population, controlled the House of Representatives in which representation is determined by the number of people in a state. The South, however, was able to check this power in the Senate where every state has two Senators regardless of size.

On August 8, 1846, the House approved a proposal by Representative David Wilmot from Pennsylvania known as the Wilmot Proviso. It would have prevented the expansion of slavery into any territory taken from Mexico. The proviso came in the form of an amendment to an appropriations bill, which was not voted on by the Senate that year before the Senate adjourned. Determined to keep the initiative alive, however, the House passed the proviso again on February 1, 1847. The Senate voted it down, and ultimately the issue of slavery would be eventually addressed in the package of legislation known as the Compromise of 1850. Essentially, slavery would be permitted in certain parts of the territory taken from Mexico if the residents wished it.

As a practical matter, the issue was rather trivial, given the small population of the region and the outbreak of the Civil War just a few years later in 1860, which inevitable abolished slavery. Regardless, the dispute over the Wilmot Proviso inflamed passions on both sides over slavery and made many northerners concerned over the future of the United States with such a divided sectional political system. These concerns helped lead in part to the creation of the Republican Party with its strong antislavery platform.