Clemency
Clemency is a legal mechanism that provides a means for reducing or eliminating the punishments of convicted individuals within the criminal justice system. It generally serves as a last resort after all avenues of appeal have been exhausted, although it can be granted at various stages of legal proceedings. There are several forms of clemency, including pardons, which nullify the punishment and restore the individual's rights as if the offense never occurred, and commutations, which modify a sentence to a lesser punishment. Additionally, reprieves offer temporary postponements of sentences, often in death penalty cases, allowing for the possibility of new evidence to be presented.
Clemency is seen by some as a vital aspect of restorative justice, particularly in contexts where mandatory sentencing may result in disproportionate penalties. This legal tool highlights the potential for mercy within a sometimes rigid judicial framework, reflecting the importance of individual circumstances in the pursuit of fairness. Between 1977 and 2023, there were 313 clemencies granted in capital murder cases in the United States, illustrating its application in high-stakes situations. Overall, clemency represents a complex intersection of law, ethics, and social justice concerns, inviting diverse perspectives on its role in the justice system.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Clemency
SIGNIFICANCE: Clemency generally serves as a last-ditch effort to secure justice for convicted individuals.
In each of the fifty US states, convicted defendants may appeal their sentences or punishments through a proscribed appeals process. When all steps of the appeals process have been exhausted, the sentences stand unless an executive body grants clemency. In rare instances, clemency may be granted at any step of the legal procedure, even prior to arraignment on charges.
Clemency may take several forms. Pardons nullify punishments and sentences, and all rights of the individual are restored as though no wrongdoing had ever occurred. By contrast, commutation of sentences acts as an exchange of the punishments originally ordered by courts with other sentences, usually sentences that are less severe. For example, a governor may commute a death-penalty sentence to life imprisonment or a ten-year prison sentence to deportation.
Executive bodies may issue clemency in the form of reprieves from sentences, that is, temporary postponements. Reprieves are most often used for death-penalty cases in which proponents of the convicted inmates seek to keep the inmates from being put to death, while simultaneously hoping to bring forward new evidence that will reverse prior appeals decisions.
Because many states have adopted mandatory sentencing for certain criminal convictions, the courts are occasionally required to impose sentences that seem out of proportion to the crimes, when all facts, exigencies, and personalities are taken into account. The possibility of clemency thus allows for restorative justice in such instances. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, 313 clemencies had been granted in capital murder cases in the United States between 1977 and 2023.
Bibliography
Burnett, Cathleen. Justice Denied: Clemency Appeals in Death Penalty Cases. Boston: Northeastern University Press, 2002.
“Clemency.” Death Penalty Information Center, 2024, deathpenaltyinfo.org/facts-and-research/clemency. Accessed 24 June 2024.
Carter, Linda E., and Ellen Krietzberg. Understanding Capital Punishment Law. Newark, N.J.: LexisNexis, 2004.