Defensive wounds and criminal investigations
Defensive wounds are injuries sustained by victims while attempting to protect themselves during violent attacks. These types of wounds are crucial in criminal investigations as they provide significant insights into the nature of the crime, often revealing details about the assailant's actions, the weapon used, and the dynamics of the struggle. Commonly located on the forearms and palms, defensive wounds can also appear on other body parts, such as the lower legs and feet, particularly in cases where victims attempt to kick their attackers. The presence or absence of defensive wounds can inform investigators about the victim's response to the attack; for instance, a lack of defensive injuries does not necessarily indicate compliance, as factors such as surprise, incapacitation, or being overpowered may play a role. In addition to physical injuries, defensive encounters may yield other evidence, such as skin cells under the victim's fingernails, which can be analyzed for DNA. The examination of defensive wounds is vital for reconstructing crime scenes and understanding the sequence of events during violent incidents. Overall, defensive wounds are a key aspect of forensic investigations, highlighting the complexities of victim responses in criminal situations.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Defensive wounds and criminal investigations
DEFINITION: Injuries received by victims as the result of trying to defend themselves during physical attacks.
SIGNIFICANCE: Defensive wounds can provide key pieces of evidence during investigations of criminal acts. Because they are inflicted on victims while the crimes are being committed, they can reveal a great deal about the crimes themselves.
Defensive wounds often occur during crimes of violence, such as homicides, rapes, and other assaults. Most such wounds are found on victims’ forearms and palms of hands, but they can also be found on other parts, such as the lower legs and feet of victims who attempt to kick their attackers. Defensive wounds are typically inflicted by knives or other sharp instruments or result from from objects such as baseball bats and hammers. Less commonly, defensive wounds are inflicted by firearms.
Defensive wounds can reveal where perpetrators were in relation to their victims, what types of weapons they used, and the amount of force they used. Such wounds can also be important in reconstructing the time lines of crime scenes, and they may produce other kinds of evidence. For example, blood from wounds may leave smears or spatters. When victims scratch their attackers—as they often do in physical struggles—traces of the attackers’ skin cells can almost always be found under the victims’ fingernails. These traces can be scraped, and the (deoxyribonucleic acid) they contain can be analyzed. At the same time, considerable amounts of trace and can be transferred between victims and their attackers.
A popular misconception about defensive wounds is that if they are not found on victims’ bodies, the victims must not have chosen to fight back or were compliant. This is often untrue, especially in cases of sexual assault. An absence of defensive injuries may indicate several possible sequences of events. For example, victims may fight back without sustaining any injuries. They may be too frightened or shocked to resist. More frequently, however, victims simply cannot fight back, usually because they are quickly overpowered or are incapacitated during the attacks. Victims may be asleep or rendered unconscious through the use of drugs or alcohol during their attacks. Victims might also be caught unaware by their attackers and thus not have time to fight back. When the body of a victim has many fresh wounds, none of which seems to be defensive in nature, it may mean that the victim was already dead or unconscious when the wounds were inflicted. The victim may also have been restrained to prevent defensive movements.
Bibliography
Handlos, Petr, et al. "Review of Patterns in Homicides by Sharp Force: One Institution's Experience." Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology, vol. 19, 2023, pp. 525-533, doi.org/10.1007/s12024-023-00576-8. Accessed 15 Aug. 2024.
Hopping, Lorraine Jean. The Body as Evidence. Milwaukee: Gareth Stevens, 2007.
Houck, Max M. Forensic Science: Modern Methods of Solving Crime. Westport, Conn.: Praeger, 2007.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗, ed. Mute Witnesses: Trace Evidence Analysis. San Diego, Calif.: Academic Press, 2001.