Five Finger Exercise by Peter Shaffer
"Five Finger Exercise" is a play by Peter Shaffer that delves into the complex dynamics of the Harrington family during a holiday at their Suffolk cottage. The title, which alludes to a piano exercise, reflects the play’s musical undertones and its exploration of character conflicts, as each of the five characters grapples with their emotional struggles. The family consists of a pretentious mother, Louise; a successful, working-class father, Stanley; their troubled son, Clive; their spirited daughter, Pamela; and Walter, a young German music tutor. Walter serves as a catalyst for revealing the family's underlying tensions and facilitates discussions that lead to potential resolutions.
Through the interactions with Walter, the characters confront their resentments, such as Louise's feelings of stiflement and Clive's sense of unappreciation. The narrative escalates to a crisis when Walter's attempt to take his own life prompts the family to recognize his contributions to their lives. Themes of artistic sensitivity versus societal norms are central to the play, highlighting the challenges faced by individuals in expressing their true selves. Shaffer’s autobiographical influences add depth to the characters' struggles, making "Five Finger Exercise" a poignant examination of familial relationships and personal identity.
On this Page
Five Finger Exercise by Peter Shaffer
Excerpted from an article in Magill’s Survey of World Literature, Revised Edition
First produced: 1958 (first published, 1958)
Type of work: Play
The Work
Originally titled Retreats, the current title, Five Finger Exercise, is a clever and symbolic reference to a piano exercise for pianists. The play has five characters that must “exorcise” their conflicts, and piano music is used throughout to underscore and punctuate dramatically heightened moments. Shaffer has admitted the autobiographical nature of the play, stating in the preface to his collected plays that it “expressed a great deal of my own family tensions and also a desperate need to stop feeling invisible.”
The play focuses on the Harrington family, who are spending a holiday together in their cottage in Suffolk, England. There is a snobbish mother, Louise, who fancies herself a Parisian aristocrat; a working class father, Stanley, who has done quite well for himself and his family in the furniture business; a troubled and sensitive son, Clive, who is just entering college, drinks too much, and is trying to find himself; and a smart-mouthed, feisty, fourteen-year-old daughter, Pamela. The fifth character is a young German music tutor, Walter, employed by the Harringtons to teach Pamela to play piano.
Walter acts as a catalyst for the family in bringing their underlying resentments out into the open for discussion and resolution. Louise resents Stanley for stifling her creative nature, while Stanley dismisses Clive’s yearning for something more fulfilling than making furniture. Pamela thinks her brother is spoiled, and Clive feels unappreciated and misunderstood by his father. Walter, however, expresses only happiness and gratitude that he has found a family and a safe place to live. In conversations with each family member, Walter helps them see their situations more objectively, which helps them find solutions to their problems. He is the model of what Clive should become: an independent, self-sufficient, educated, and artistic young man, who is comfortable with himself.
Clive is jealous of his mother’s attentions toward Walter and tells his father that they are having an affair, but he later regrets it when Walter proves to be his true friend. Once Louise and Stanley agree to go away together in an effort to save their marriage, Louise turns against Walter and asks Stanley to dismiss him. Although Walter begs to stay with the family, they remain firm, blaming Walter for their children’s problems.
While Walter plays his gramophone upstairs, Louise learns about Clive’s lie and rejects his apology. In the midst of their argument, Walter’s record skips, and when Stanley knocks on his door he discovers that Walter has attempted to commit suicide by turning on the gas in his room. The others galvanize to save him, as they seem to suddenly realize what Walter has done for them, and he is resuscitated. The play ends with Clive praying for courage, which Gene A. Plunka, in his book Peter Shaffer: Roles, Rites, and Rituals in the Theater (1988), defines as “adhering to one’s own norms and values no matter how different they are from the . . . accepted societal mores and standards.”
This play deals in part with the difference between the truly artistic, romantic, and sensitive versus those who do not understand them. Shaffer explores this theme again in Private Ear and most effectively in Equus, when creativity and theatricality in his playwriting reach a summit.
Bibliography
Cohn, Ruby. Currents in Contemporary Drama. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1969.
Cooke, Virginia, and Malcolm Page, comps. File on Shaffer. New York: Methuen, 1987.
Dean, Joan F. “Peter Shaffer’s Recurrent Character Type.” Modern Drama 21 (September, 1978): 297-305.
Elsom, John. Post-War British Theatre. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1976.
Gianakaris, C. J. Peter Shaffer. New York: Macmillan, 1992.
Gianakaris, C. J. Peter Shaffer: A Casebook. Garland Reference Library of the Humanities 1291; Casebooks on Modern Dramatists 10. New York: Garland, 1991.
King, Kimball. TwentyModern British Playwrights: A Bibliography, 1956 to 1976. New York: Garland, 1977.
King, Kimball, ed. Modern Dramatists: A Casebook of Major British, Irish, and American Playwrights. New York: Routledge, 2001.
Klein, Dennis A. Peter Shaffer. Rev. ed. New York: Twayne, 1993.
Lounsberry, Barbara. “’God-Hunting.’ The Chaos of Worship in Peter Shaffer’s Equus and Royal Hunt of the Sun.” Modern Drama 21 (March, 1978): 13-28.
MacMurraugh-Kavanagh, M. K. Peter Shaffer: Theatre and Drama. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1998.
Plunka, Gene A. Peter Shaffer: Roles, Rites, and Rituals in the Theater. London: Associated University Presses, 1988.
Taylor, John Russell. Peter Shaffer. Edited by Ian Scott-Kilvert. New York: Longman, 1974.
Thomas, Eberle. Peter Shaffer: An Annotated Bibliography. New York: Garland, 1991.