Low-carb diet trends in the 2000s
In the 2000s, low-carb diets gained significant popularity as a response to rising concerns about weight and metabolic disorders, particularly in the United States. These diets typically focus on reducing or eliminating certain carbohydrates, contrasting with the low-fat dietary trends of the previous decade. The Atkins diet, which began to take off in 2002, became one of the most recognized low-carb programs, prompting research into its health implications. While low-carb diets can lead to weight loss by shifting the body’s energy source from carbohydrates to fat, they also raise concerns regarding potential health risks, including kidney damage and nutrient deficiencies, due to the elimination of essential food groups.
Many low-carb diets involve a phased approach, starting with a significant reduction in carbohydrate intake and gradually reintroducing specific types. Some variations, like the South Beach diet, incorporate the glycemic index to prioritize healthier carbohydrate choices. Despite their popularity, health organizations, such as the Centers for Disease Control and the American Association of Family Physicians, have advocated for a balanced approach that includes a higher percentage of healthy carbohydrates in daily diets. Overall, while low-carb diets offer short-term benefits for weight loss, their long-term health implications remain a topic of ongoing research and debate.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Low-carb diet trends in the 2000s
Food restriction plans that greatly minimize or eliminate specific carbohydrates
Together with fats and proteins, carbohydrates (carbs) are one of the three macronutrients, or energy-containing nutrients, of the human diet. Low-carb diets, which reduce or eliminate certain carbohydrates, can be short-lived, calorie-restrictive fads, or they can be tiered weight-loss programs that replace carbohydrate calories with another macronutrient.
As the number of Americans with metabolic disorders like diabetes climb, low-carbohydrate diets that aim to reduce weight by lowering sugar intake outpace the heart-healthy, low-fat diets of the 1990s, such as the American Heart Association diet. Although varied low-carb programs exist, the Atkins diet, which became popular starting in 2002, in large part spurred research efforts to determine the true benefits and risks of these programs.
The starches, refined sugars, and fructose prevalent in American diets are all types of carbohydrates that cause more rapid glucose peaks in the body than complex wheat and grains. When a diet with fewer than a hundred grams of daily carbohydrates is implemented, the body burns its own fat sources instead of using daily carbohydrate intake for energy. However, this ketosis, or fat breakdown, can cause kidney damage and malnutrition. Nonselective carbohydrate elimination and increased protein or fat intake also deprive the body of essential nutrients, such as calcium or folate, and potentially increase heart disease risks.
Careful low-carb diets distinguish between nutritive and damaging carbohydrate sources instead of relying on strict calorie-counting techniques alone. For example, the glycemic index (GI) that was developed in 1980 is a calculation that reflects a carbohydrate’s effect on blood sugar levels. The South Beach diet, originally designed to minimize fat intake and heart disease, is one such low-carb variant diet. The program incorporates GI measurements into food recommendations on the premise that carbohydrate-rich processed foods adversely affect satiety, or fullness, and weight as much as trans fat. The 2005 Centers for Disease Control Dietary Guidelines for Americans similarly emphasizes fiber-rich carbohydrate choices instead of limiting amounts of carbohydrate foods.
Low-carb diets by definition limit carbohydrate intake instead of emphasizing better carbohydrate choices, and each low-carb diet has its own restrictions about types and amounts of carbohydrates. Many involve preliminary purges, followed by stepwise reintroduction of particular carbohydrate sources and a final maintenance plan. For example, the Atkins diet institutes a four-phase program that begins with only twenty net grams of carbohydrates each day from a small selection of foods. According to the American Association of Family Physicians, most low-carb diets reduce carbohydrates to fewer than 20 percent of the day’s calories. The US Dietary Association, however, recommended in 2009 that 45 to 65 percent of a daily diet consist of healthy carbohydrates including fiber, whole grains, and fruits.
Impact
Although low-carb diets have improved significantly in safety and product selection since their initiation in the 1970s, the programs that became popular in the 2000s remained inadequate long-term health solutions for many. Professional research into healthful carbohydrate balance has contributed to more appropriate application of these diets without increasing cardiac or metabolic risks.
Bibliography
Atkins, Robert C. Dr. Atkins’ New Diet Revolution. New York: Harper, 2002. Print.
Bazzano, Lydia A., et al. "Effects of Low-Carbohydrate and Low-Fat Diets." Annals of Internal Medicine 161.5 (2014): 309–18. Print.
Freeman, Janine, and Charlotte Hayes. “Low Carbohydrate Food Facts and Fallacies.” Diabetes Spectrum 17.3 (2004): 137–40. Print.
US Department of Health and Human Services. “Health Facts: Choose Carbohydrates Wisely.” Washington, DC: US Dept. of Health and Human Services, n.d. PDF file.
"What to Make of Low-Carb Promises?" Running and FitNews Sept./Oct. 2014: 5–7. Print.