Mayoralty in the United States
Mayoralty in the United States is a political role that has evolved significantly since its origins in thirteenth-century England, where it was created to govern small towns. The position was introduced in North America with the English colonization but initially held limited power, as early citizens preferred a council-based governance model over a singular authority. Over time, the role of mayor expanded, with many towns transitioning from appointed to elected mayors, reflecting a desire for increased accountability and centralized local government.
Today, the structure of mayoral governance varies across municipalities. In some systems, a strong city council holds more power than a weak mayor, while in others, a strong mayor leads with considerable authority over city management, including hiring and budget approvals. Additionally, in council-manager systems, the mayor acts as a member of the city council, guiding legislative decisions while often serving as a representative for public interests. This diverse framework of mayoralty allows for a range of governance styles, from centralized power to more community-driven models, including town meetings. Understanding these variations can provide insights into the political dynamics and local governance in different regions of the United States.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Mayoralty in the United States
The mayor is a political position found throughout the United States. It originated in the thirteenth century in England, where it was created to help govern small towns. When the English created colonies in North America, they brought their forms of local governance to the New World.
Originally, the position of mayor was politically weak. Colonists and early Americans were wary of putting too much power in a single official. However, over time, the power of the mayoral office increased. As its political power increased, many towns changed the office from an appointed position to an elected one.
Modern mayors can have several jobs. In some governments, they help manage a city in addition to a city council. In this style of government, the mayor is often responsible for hiring, firing, and appointing city officials. The mayor may also be responsible for approving a city’s budget. In other local governments, the mayor may be a part of the city council. In this style of government, the mayor leads the city council, using his or her influence to guide the governing body’s policy decisions. In both of these systems, the mayoral position may be strong or weak, accounting for the level of responsibility he or she holds.
Background
The origins of the political position of mayor coupled with a city council date back centuries. The first mayors were elected in the thirteenth century in England. The town charters granted wealthy men the ability to elect a mayor and city council to help manage the town. Over time, this style of governance became more popular in England.
When England became a colonial power, it began to send English citizens to settle other parts of the world. Thirteen English colonies were located in North America. North American colonists used many of the same systems of governance as their predecessors in England, including the creation of a council and mayor to help run municipalities. However, in the colonies, mayors were not always elected by their constituents. Instead, they might be appointed by the governor.
After the colonies rebelled against England and became the United States of America, the mayoral form of local government remained. However, city councils instead of colonial governors were allowed to appoint mayors. Additionally, the office of mayor was intentionally kept weak and ceremonial. The citizens of the early United States were more willing to trust a council with legislative power than a single appointed individual.
In the nineteenth century, some towns began to adopt a stronger mayoral figure. They wanted a more centralized form of local government. During this period, some American towns also transitioned from an appointed mayor to an elected mayor. The populations of those towns sought to balance a stronger mayor with greater accountability to the people.
Over time, elected mayor positions grew more popular. They spread throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. In modern America, towns that utilize mayoral systems can be found across the nation.
Overview
The mayor is a position in many forms of local government. In most cases, the job of the mayor is to oversee the city’s main departments and the general functions of the city. However, there are many types of local governments, and the responsibilities and powers of the mayor vary between each style.
One of the most common forms of local government is that consisting of a strong city council and a weak mayoral office. In this type of government, the city council and the mayor share authority over most matters of governance. However, the city council is substantially more powerful than the office of the mayor. Often in this form, the mayor has limited or no veto power.
In another form of local government, a strong mayor works with a weaker city council. In this system, the council leads the city’s legislature while the mayor is responsible for most other aspects of local government. This includes establishing, managing, and maintaining administrative offices. The mayor also hires and fires city staff and has veto power over any legislation passed by the city council.
In the council-manager system, the mayor is a member of the city council. He or she usually acts as the leader and manager of the city council. In this circumstance, the city council manages most of the affairs of the city. The manager may still appoint, hire, or fire city staff, depending on laws of the local area. However, in this form of government, the mayor often has more power than a strict interpretation of the office would convey. As the head of the city council, the mayor acts as its representative to the public. This allows the mayor to use public opinion and political influence to push forward favorable policies and hinder unfavorable legislation.
In many cases, the mayor is responsible for preparing the annual budget. This means receiving the budget prepared by the city manager or chief administrative official and agreeing or disagreeing with the proposed budget. This gives the mayor substantial authority over how a town or city’s money may be spent.
Mayoralty and mayor-council governments feature a more centralized style of power than their common alternatives, including the town meeting and representative town meeting styles of government. In a town meeting style of government, all eligible voters in a town come together on a set date to discuss and debate policy decisions for their municipality. They then vote on these decisions, which are carried out by a board of elected officials. Representative town meeting governments function similarly, except that only a small number of citizens elected as representatives can vote. While these government styles may work well for small towns, they sometimes suffer from low voter turnout for important issues.
Bibliography
“Forms of Municipal Government.” National League of Cities, 2018, www.nlc.org/forms-of-municipal-government. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.
“Mayor-Council Government.” Ballotpedia, 2018, ballotpedia.org/Mayor-council‗government. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.
Neiger, Christopher. “How Mayors Work.” HowStuffWorks, 2018, people.howstuffworks.com/government/local-politics/mayor1.htm. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.
“Open Town Meeting.” Ballotpedia, 2018, ballotpedia.org/Open‗town‗meeting. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.
"Roles and Responsibilities of Local Government Leaders." MRSC, mrsc.org/explore-topics/officials/roles/roles-and-responsibilities. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.
"The Shifting Role of Mayors in Local Governance." Giving Compass, 7 Nov. 2024, givingcompass.org/article/the-shifting-role-of-mayors-in-local-governance. Accessed 11 Feb. 2025.