Guest worker programs
Guest worker programs are government-sponsored initiatives that allow the temporary importation of laborers from other countries to fill specific job vacancies in the host country, often in sectors such as agriculture. In the United States, notable examples include the bracero program, which operated from 1942 to 1964, bringing millions of Mexican agricultural workers to address labor shortages during World War II. These programs have a complex history, with early forms resembling indentured servitude, which has evolved over time into structured visa categories, such as H1B for specialized occupations and H2A and H2B for seasonal workers.
While guest worker programs are designed to meet labor needs, they have faced significant scrutiny regarding labor conditions, the impact on local job markets, and the treatment of workers. Critics argue that existing frameworks can lead to workplace abuses and create a system where employers are insulated from labor market dynamics. Political discourse around guest worker programs is diverse, with some advocating for labor protections and others seeking to expand these programs for economic reasons. In recent years, there has been an increasing focus on enhancing protections for guest workers in response to concerns about exploitation and human trafficking. Overall, guest worker programs remain a contentious issue, balancing labor demands with ethical considerations and immigration policy.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Guest worker programs
DEFINITION: Government-sponsored programs permitting the temporary importation of workers in specific occupations
SIGNIFICANCE: Guest-worker programs in the United States, such as the mid-century bracero program, have often met with controversy due to variable labor conditions and their perceived effect on American wages and job availability.
Guest-worker programs import laborers from other countries into the United States for temporary employment. Early variants of such programs included indentured servitude during the colonial period, when European immigrant workers agreed to fixed terms of labor in exchange for transportation and other costs. The recruiting of Chinese railroad workers and other forms of contract labor during the mid-nineteenth century were also forms of indentured servitude; they were eventually outlawed by the Foran Act of 1885. Another form of indentured servitude was the nineteenth-century Italian padrone system, which was facilitated by labor contractors with transatlantic ties. These early forms of indentured servitude did not always require that the laborers return to their home countries at the end of their terms of service, but many indentured laborers did.
The best-known guest-worker arrangement in the United States was the bracero program, which imported millions of Mexican agricultural laborers between 1942 and 1964. The imposition of this program required the repeal of the Foran Act, but growers’ associations successfully convinced the US Congress that manpower shortages during World War II required new sources of farm labor. The program ended in 1964 amid increased scrutiny by labor regulators and in face of competition from the widespread mechanization of agricultural work.
During the early twenty-first century, President George W. Bush’s proposal to expand guest-worker programs met with significant criticism across the political spectrum. He reduced oversight of the certification process for guest-worker visas toward the end of his time in office; President Barack Obama reverted that change in 2010. As of 2018, the United States continues to allow guest workers on "H-visas," primarily H1B (workers in fields requiring specialized knowledge), H2A (seasonal or temporary agricultural workers), and H2B (seasonal or temporary workers in fields other than agriculture). These categories along with H4 (for spouses and unmarried children of H-visa workers) accounted for more than 530,000 visas in 2016. H1B and H2B visas have an annual cap on the number that can be issued, with exemptions that result in the number of visas issued often being well above the cap.
President Donald Trump stated a desire to reduce the number of guest workers as part of an overall effort to reduce immigration in all forms and prioritize US citizens in hiring. In 2017, a Republican-controlled Congress voted to remove some of the exemptions to the H2B cap of 66,000 visas, effectively lowering the number of visas that could be issued. When businesses had trouble filling seasonal positions as a result, the cap was raised to 15,000. That year, Trump also directed federal agencies to review the H1B process. Various reforms to the H1B, H2A, and H2B programs have been suggested by politicians across the political spectrum. Democratic politicians have generally been concerned with increasing protections for guest workers and ensuring that they are paid the same amount that a US citizen in the same position would be. Many Republicans want to expand the guest worker programs as a source of less expensive labor, though some, like Trump, want to reduce the number of visas issued.
2024: Workplace Protections
In the 2020s, the issue of immigration reached the forefront of American politics. Media scenes describing a chaotic and dangerous environment in US border areas, however inaccurate or overblown, did have the effect of making the issue resonate with voters. For the first time in decades, a majority of the American electorate held negative sentiments toward migration. Both major US political parties issued policy declarations, mainly on the need for stricter border controls.
Guest workers appeared for many as a method where controlled entry of migrants could address both security and labor concerns. There were, however, many critics of existing guest worker programs. Detractors brought forth issues with abuses that existed in the H-2A and H-2B programs. Calling the structure "flawed," critics maintained it created a captive market and insulated employers from US labor market supply and demand trends. This process also exposed guest workers to workplace abuses. In such cases, the reporting of employers did not occur for fear of retaliation. In April 2024, the US Department of Labor announced changes to protections afforded to guest workers. Several of these included the following:
- Protections for self-advocacy
- More transparent rules on the ability of employers to terminate employment "for cause"
- Increased government visibility on employer recruitment processes
- Methods to eliminate human trafficking
Bibliography
Bustamante, Jorge, Clark Reynolds, and Raul Hinojosa Ojeda. U.S.-Mexico Relations: Labor Market Interdependence. Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1992.
Campbell, Alexia Fernández. "Trump Lifted the Cap on H-2B Worker Visas. Then His Businesses Asked for 76 of Them." Vox, 20 July 2017, www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/7/20/16003254/trump-h2b-visa-program. Accessed 4 Oct. 2018.
Felter, Claire. "US Temporary Foreign Worker Programs." Council on Foreign Relations, 30 May 2017, www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-temporary-foreign-worker-programs. Accessed 4 Oct. 2018.
"Guestworker Programs." Farmworker Justice, www.farmworkerjustice.org/advocacy‗program/guestworker-programs. Accessed 9 Sept. 2024.
Griffith, David. American Guestworkers: Jamaicans and Mexicans in the U.S. Labor Market. University Park, Pennsylvania State University Press, 2006.
Jordan, Don. White Cargo: The Forgotten History of Britain’s White Slaves in America. New York, New York University Press, 2008.
Ngai, Mae M. Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. Princeton, Princeton University Press, 2004.
Nowrasteh, Alex. "Border Chaos and the Catch-22 of Immigration Reform." CATO Institute, 10 Aug. 2022, www.cato.org/blog/border-chaos-catch-22-immigration-reform. Sept. 10, 2024.
"US Department of Labor Finalizes Farmworker Protection Rule." US Department of Labor, 26 Apr. 2024, www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/whd/whd20240426. Accessed 10 Sept. 2024.