Kohl Becomes Chancellor of West Germany

Date October 1, 1982

The Free Democratic Party’s abandonment of its twelve-year coalition with the Social Democratic Party and its new alliance with the Christian Democratic party led to the first successful “constructive vote of no confidence” in the West German Bundestag, allowing Helmut Kohl to replace Helmut Schmidt as chancellor on October 1, 1982.

Locale Bonn, West Germany

Key Figures

  • Helmut Kohl (1930–2017), chancellor of West Germany, 1982–1990, and Germany, 1990–1998
  • Helmut Schmidt (1918–2015), chancellor of West Germany, 1974–1982
  • Hans-Dietrich Genscher (1927–2016), foreign minister and vice chancellor of West Germany, 1974–1990, and Germany, 1990–1992
  • Franz Josef Strauss (1915–1988), minister-president of Bavaria, 1978–1988
  • Willy Brandt (Herbert Ernst Karl Frahm; 1913–1992), chancellor of West Germany, 1969–1974
  • Petra Kelly (1947–1992), founding member and a leader of the German Green Party, 1980–1990
  • Otto Lambsdorff (1926–2009), minister of economics of West Germany, 1977–1984

Summary of Event

In 1982, the West German government led by Chancellor Helmut Schmidt was based on a coalition of the Social Democratic Party (SPD) and the Free Democratic Party (FDP) first established in 1969. Thanks to the support of the liberal FDP, Willy Brandt became the first Socialist chancellor of West Germany in 1969, providing an alternative to the conservative Christian Democratic Union and Christian Social Union of Bavaria (CDU/CSU) chancellors who had dominated that position since 1949. The small FDP, which supported Christian Democratic chancellors before 1966, represented the crucial swing party between the SPD and CDU/CSU coalition, the two largest West German parties. After the discovery of an East German spy on Brandt’s staff, Brandt was forced to resign on May 6, 1974. Schmidt became the new chancellor, and the FDP leader Hans-Dietrich Genscher assumed the crucial post of foreign minister.

89315218-63760.jpg

Schmidt’s coalition won the elections in 1980, but within two years the coalition succumbed to internal strains. One issue, which had united the majority of Free Democrats with the Socialists, was support of a policy of détente with the Soviet Union and East European countries (Ostpolitik) first initiated by Brandt. This policy, which involved de facto recognition of the loss of German territory to Poland after 1945, was initially bitterly opposed by the Christian Democrats, and particularly by Franz Josef Strauss, the leader of the Bavarian branch, the Christian Social Union. Moreover, Strauss’s social conservatism alienated Genscher and many in his party. It was only after Strauss failed in his candidacy for chancellor in the election of 1980 that this obstacle to an FDP-CDU alliance was removed. Helmut Kohl, who accepted Ostpolitik and was on friendly terms with Genscher, emerged as the acknowledged and moderate leader of the CDU.

Before 1982, Schmidt, who was not the chair of the SPD, also faced serious obstacles from members of his own party. Many SPD members rejected efforts to cut social benefits or to raise indirect taxes to deal with increasing economic problems faced by the government. In addition, the chancellor’s foreign and defense policy, in response to what he considered Soviet threats, was rejected by an increasing number of Socialists. Still, the most active and passionate opposition to the government’s military and ecological policies came from the Green Party, a new party organized in January, 1980, whose most effective spokesperson was Petra Kelly. The Greens drained support from the SPD and further weakened Schmidt’s position.

Even though Schmidt faced serious opposition to his policies from within the SPD and the new Green movement, Genscher and the majority of FDP members of the cabinet caused the collapse of the coalition government in September, 1982. Genscher claimed in his memoirs that he was afraid that the SPD would sabotage his foreign policy, but in truth he, not Kohl, coined the word Wende (turning point) in a letter to FDP leaders in August, 1981, that criticized Schmidt’s economic policies. The FDP minister of economics, Count Otto Lambsdorff, also attacked the economic policies of the SPD. By March, 1982, the FDP declared its support for a coalition with the CDU in the state of Lower Saxony. The evidence was clear that Genscher was preparing to abandon Schmidt. In the September, 1982, state election in Hesse, the FDP openly assaulted the SPD. Lambsdorff suggested that election results in Hesse could have a direct impact on the Bonn government. In order to force the hand of the FDP, Schmidt demanded that Lambsdorff produce an economic policy paper. On September 9, Lambsdorff presented an extreme supply-side program with significant reductions in public expenditures, which he knew the SPD would never accept. Eight days later, after Schmidt had revealed his decision to address the Bundestag and accuse the FDP of the collapse of the government, all FDP ministers resigned.

Schmidt hoped to force new elections, which might result in the failure of the FDP to obtain the necessary 5 percent of the vote to return to the Bundestag. Instead, Genscher, fearing elections at this time, convinced a majority of the FDP to ally with the Christian Democrats. By September 21, the CDU/CSU accepted the FDP offer and, using a constructive no confidence vote on October 1, 1982 (which required a majority for the new government), the Bundestag elected Kohl chancellor with a vote of 256 to 235. The only other attempt to use the constructive no confidence vote in West Germany by the CDU in April, 1972, barely failed to obtain a majority of the Bundestag vote, and the Socialist Brandt remained in power.

Kohl kept Genscher as foreign minister, a position that Strauss wanted. In order to consolidate his power, Kohl, on December 17, 1982, decided to arrange a deliberate vote of no confidence in the Bundestag in order to force new elections before the regularly scheduled elections in 1984. The president of West Germany, Karl Carsten, accepted this move in January, 1983, as did the Federal Constitutional Court on February 16, 1983. In the election in March, Kohl easily defeated the SPD candidate, Hans-Jochen Vogel, Schmidt’s minister of justice and former mayor of Munich. The CDU/CSU won 48.6 percent of the vote, the party’s second best showing since 1949, and the FDP won only 6.9 percent of the vote. The first new party since 1957 to enter the Bundestag, the Greens (5.6 percent), drew votes from the SPD, which declined to 38 percent.

Significance

Kohl became the longest-serving chancellor of West Germany (and reunified Germany), holding that office until 1998. Nine years earlier, the cover story of the German magazine Der Spiegel predicted that Kohl had no future. Continuously underestimated, Kohl skillfully maintained his coalition with the FDP and won four Bundestag elections until he was finally defeated in September, 1998. As the first German leader since 1949 who was not an adult during Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich, Kohl felt more comfortable than his predecessors in appealing to national pride.

Kohl’s greatest contributions came in the field of foreign affairs. He accepted Ostpolitik and invited the leader of the communist German Democratic Republic (DDR, or East Germany), Erich Honecker, to visit Bonn in 1987. Taking advantage of the collapse of the DDR regime in November, 1989, Kohl initiated a process that led to the reunification of the two German states in October, 1990. Together with French president François Mitterrand, Kohl played a major role in negotiating the Maastricht Treaty of 1992, which provided for further European integration leading to the European Union and the common currency, the euro. Timothy Garton Ash, a well-known observer of European affairs, called Kohl “the most formidable . . . statesman in Europe,” and former US president George H. W. Bush was quoted in Time Europe as stating that Kohl was “the greatest European leader of the second half of the twentieth century.”

Bibliography

Bering, Henrik. Helmut Kohl. Regnery, 1999.

Clemens, Clay, and William E. Paterson. The Kohl Chancellorship. Frank Cass, 1998.

"Kohl Elected West German Chancellor." History, A&E Television Networks, 2017, www.history.com/this-day-in-history/kohl-elected-west-german-chancellor. Accessed 7 Jul. 2017.

Oltermann, Philip. "Helmut Kohl, Germany's Reunification Chancellor, Dies Aged 87." The Guardian, 16 June 2017, www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/16/helmut-kohl-ex-chancellor-and-architect-of-german-reunification-dies-aged-87. Accessed 7 July 2017.

Strong, Carol R. The Role of Charismatic Leadership in Ending the Cold War: The Presidencies of Boris Yeltsin, Vaclav Havel, and Helmut Kohl. Edwin Mellen Press, 2009.