Legitimacy (political)
Political legitimacy refers to the perception and acceptance of authority by the governed population, affecting how people view their government and its right to rule. When a government enjoys high legitimacy, citizens believe in its authority and are more inclined to follow laws and regulations willingly, often viewing their compliance as a moral obligation. Conversely, low legitimacy can lead to public discontent, rebellion, or noncompliance, as individuals question the government's right to govern. Various factors contribute to political legitimacy, including a government's ability to meet the basic needs of its citizens, such as safety, healthcare, and economic stability. Different forms of government, such as authoritarian regimes and democracies, employ distinct strategies to cultivate legitimacy. Authoritarian governments may emphasize stability and order, while democracies often promote citizen participation and free elections as essential components of legitimacy. The concept can also extend beyond governments to include other authorities, such as police forces, where public trust and acceptance of their authority are vital for effective governance and cooperation. Understanding political legitimacy is crucial, as it reflects the relationship between authority and the people governed, influencing social order and compliance.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Legitimacy (political)
Political legitimacy is a measure of the general feelings of a population toward its government. In areas with high legitimacy, the people believe that the government has a right to rule. They approve of the government and are more likely to follow the rules and regulations decided upon by the government. In areas with low legitimacy, the people do not believe the government has a right to rule. They may be more disorderly, more resistant to authority, and more likely to refuse to follow the laws.
Governments use numerous tactics to increase political legitimacy. They might try to prove that they can meet the needs of the people or that they bring consistent benefits to the lives of the people. They might try to show that they have a preordained or political right to rule over the people.
Even people in areas with low political legitimacy can be forced to follow the law. However, they will do so out of a sense of coercion, further lowering political legitimacy. However, in areas with high political legitimacy, citizens may follow the law out of a sense of obligation. They believe in the government and that they are obligated to follow its regulations.
In some cases, legitimacy can apply to authority figures other than governments. One common case is police legitimacy. Police legitimacy acts as a measurement of how the public feels about the police force.
Background
Governments are organizations designed to create and enforce laws across a country. Governments have existed in some form since the dawn of recorded history. Some governments were Indigenous groups, which may have been led by a council or a series of respected elders. Other governments were monarchies, which were led by royalty. More modern styles of government, such as democracies, republics, and dictatorships, evolved over time.
Different styles of government tend to cultivate political legitimacy in different ways. Authoritarian governments, meaning governments that feature strong central power and limit political freedoms, tend to increase feelings of political legitimacy by showing that they have a right to rule. They provide the people with good living standards and show the people that the government can achieve its goals. Authoritarian governments may also use tactics like state propaganda to promote the government or make it more difficult for citizens to speak negatively about the government.
Democratic governments, meaning governments that allow the people to have significant input in the political process, also use a number of techniques to maintain high legitimacy. For example, they tend to justify their rule through the use of ideology. They also tend to advertise that the people are the ones conducting the governing and that the government is just an extension of the people. This causes the people to identify with their government. Individuals who identify with their government and believe that they have a significant say in the political process are more likely to consent to be governed. Citizens who willingly consent to be governed are likely to view their government as a legitimate source of authority.
Overview
Legitimacy refers to people’s beliefs about any given authority. It can apply to nongovernmental entities, such as police forces or leaders in organizations. However, it most commonly refers to a governed people’s beliefs about their government or governing officials. Legitimate governments are accepted by the people they govern. The people believe they need to obey the decrees of the government, including the rule of law and all other governmental powers. Governments with low legitimacy do not have the support of their people. The governed see little reason to obey the decrees of the government and often do not. In cases where a government faces an extreme lack of legitimacy, the governed may openly rebel against the government.
All governments maintain political legitimacy by showing that they are improving the lives of their citizens. Citizens are more likely to believe a government is a legitimate source of authority if the government is actively attending to their needs. These needs include providing food, shelter, healthcare, and safety. If a government fails to secure the basic needs of its citizens, the citizens may begin to wonder if they need their government, thus reducing political legitimacy.
Many citizens and political demographics have demands for their governments. They base a significant amount of their feelings of political legitimacy on how well the government meets those demands. For example, citizens accustomed to living in a democratic nation usually feel that regular, free and fair elections are an important part of a legitimate government. Should their government cease to provide free and fair elections, or provide them less often, these citizens would view the government as less of a legitimate authority.
Political experts view the concept of political legitimacy as often accompanying the concept of political obligation. If a nation or government has low political legitimacy, citizens can still be forced to perform tasks for the government. However, they may perform those tasks out of a sense of coercion. This will make the citizens unhappy, further lowering the legitimacy of the government in the eyes of its citizens. However, if a government has high political legitimacy, citizens may complete those same tasks out of a sense of moral obligation. They may also be more willing to follow the laws, rules, and regulations set forth by their government.
Legitimacy is sometimes applied to types of authorities other than governments. For example, some areas struggle with raising police legitimacy. Like political legitimacy, police legitimacy is the idea that local law enforcement has a right to their authority. High police legitimacy tends to result in increased cooperation with authority figures, while low legitimacy tends to result in decreased cooperation with authority figures.
Bibliography
Clements, Kevin. “What Is Legitimacy and Why Does It Matter for Peace?” Conciliation Resources, Apr. 2014, www.c-r.org/accord/legitimacy-and-peace-processes/what-legitimacy-and-why-does-it-matter-peace. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
Hayward, Fred M., and Ahmed R. Dumbuya. “Political Legitimacy, Political Symbols, and National Leadership in West Africa.” The Journal of Modern African Studies, 11 Nov. 2008, www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-modern-african-studies/article/political-legitimacy-political-symbols-and-national-leadership-in-west-africa/3A93805169F02D6783323B0D274D4DCD. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
Hoffman, Michael. “Government Legitimacy and Religion.” Oxford Research Encyclopedias, 26 Sept. 2018, oxfordre.com/politics/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228637-e-662. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
Ignácz, Zsófia S. "The Relationship between Political Legitimacy and Economic Legitimacy: Empirical Explorations of a Novel Research Approach on Legitimacy." Frontiers in Political Science, vol. 6, 2024, p. 1198295, doi.org/10.3389/fpos.2024.1198295. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
Mazepus, Honorata. "What Makes Political Authorities Legitimate? Students' Ideas about Legitimacy in Five European Democracies and Hybrid Regimes." Contemporary Politics, vol. 23, no. 3, 2017, pp. 306-327, doi.org/10.1080/13569775.2017.1306762. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
Peter, Fabienne. “Political Legitimacy.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 11 Dec. 2023, plato.stanford.edu/entries/legitimacy. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.
“Race, Trust, and Police Legitimacy.” National Institute of Justice, 9 Jan. 2013, www.nij.gov/topics/law-enforcement/legitimacy/pages/welcome.aspx. Accessed 26 Jan. 2025.