Dialectics (dialectical method)
Dialectics, often referred to as the dialectical method, is a conversational technique rooted in the philosophical practices of Socrates, an influential ancient Greek thinker. This method emphasizes the importance of open and honest dialogue between two participants, aiming for mutual understanding and the refinement of ideas. Socrates believed that effective communication hinges on several key principles: both individuals must genuinely seek to understand each other's perspectives, engage sincerely, and admit to contradictions in their arguments. In Socratic dialectics, lengthy and convoluted responses are discouraged to maintain clarity, promoting concise exchanges instead. The process is designed not merely as a debate but as a collaborative effort to uncover deeper truths, which can lead to meaningful relationships between participants. The dialectical method underscores the value of learning from one another, positioning contradictions not as failures but as opportunities for growth and correction. By adhering to these principles, participants strive to engage thoughtfully and foster an environment conducive to philosophical inquiry.
On this Page
Dialectics (dialectical method)
Dialectics (also known as the dialectical method) is a conversational technique pioneered by the ancient Greek philosopher Socrates. Socrates used dialectics to assess the value of other peoples' philosophical viewpoints. According to the philosopher, if correctly utilized, dialectics will lead to a mutual understanding between conversation participants. In many cases, the philosopher believed that open and honest dialogue would lead to the formation of a deeper friendship.
For a conversation to follow Socrates's standards for a dialectical discourse, it must adhere to a number of rules. It must take place between just two people. Both participants must enter the conversation with the intent of learning about the other's views, not with the intent of winning an argument. Both participants must speak honestly and openly throughout the conversation. Both participants must admit when their views are shown to be wrong or contradictory. A number of other rules for dialectical conversations are also applied.
Background
Socrates was an ancient Greek philosopher who lived from 469 to 399 BCE. He laid the foundation for much of ancient Greek philosophy, which, in turn, became the cornerstone of Western philosophy. For this reason, Socrates is commonly considered the father of Western philosophy.
Socrates had an early life typical of many ancient Greeks. His father was a stonemason, while his mother was a midwife. Greek children studied music and grammar, and they engaged in competitive sports. Socrates was no exception. When he came of age, Socrates learned stonemasonry from his father and later worked in this field.
Like many Greek men, Socrates served in the Athenian army. According to accounts from the time, Socrates was an exceptional soldier, and he even saved the life of his general. However, the future philosopher chose not to make the military his career. He returned to Athens after wartime, rededicating himself to intellectual pursuits.
According to legend, Socrates's philosophical career began with the Oracle at Delphi. The oracle was a mysterious prophetess said to have a direct link to the gods. Leaders in ancient Greece carefully heeded her input.
A friend of Socrates, Chaerephon, asked the oracle if there was anyone alive who was wiser than Socrates was. The oracle said there was not. Dismayed by this answer, Socrates set out to find people wiser than himself. He traveled across Greece, meeting with great religious leaders, generals, politicians, and common people.
Socrates was upset by the results of his travels. He found that people he expected to be the wisest were often the least intelligent. In contrast, Socrates found great wisdom and unexpected intelligence in the common people of ancient Greece. Still, Socrates continued his quest in Athens. He questioned the elders of the city in public, testing their ideas and skill in rhetoric against his own. In most cases, the elders were found wanting.
The youth of the city enjoyed watching Socrates question Athens' established leadership. Over time, Socrates developed a large following. Many of these young people decided to follow Socrates full time, devoting their lives to philosophy. Socrates's most famous student, Plato, went on to teach the famed philosopher Aristotle.
Socrates's teachings led to the development of many major Western schools of philosophy. However, the Athenian government did not appreciate his methods of questioning authority figures. Socrates was accused of denying the Athenian gods and corrupting the city's youth. The philosopher was condemned to death and then executed by poisoning.
Overview
One of Socrates's most important teachings was his style of discourse, called dialectics. Socrates believed that efficient, genuine conversation was an important part of philosophy. It allows individual thinkers to communicate, exchange ideas, and refine their own ideas. Socrates thought that if conversation were conducted in an imperfect or inefficient manner, then neither party would be able to sway the other. However, if both parties adhered to his rules of dialectics, they would be able to find common ground.
If two people intend to converse using the dialectical method, they must follow several rules. First, both participants in the discussion must have a genuine desire to understand the points of the other participant. If this is true, they will eventually come to understand the true nature of their disagreement.
A dialectical conversation must be between two individuals. If more individuals wish to be present in the conversation, they must choose representatives from among them. Socrates believed that an efficient conversation required each party to be able to devote their full attention to the other party.
When the actual dialogue begins, answers to questions must be short and concise. This helps communication remain clear. According to Socrates, long-winded, complicated replies only serve to confuse the other party. Additionally, both speakers must remain sincere and consistent. They must remain calm and freely admit when they have been caught in a contradiction. Socrates asserts that being caught in a contradiction is not shameful. It simply shows that some parts of a participant's argument are in error and allows them to reexamine and correct them. If one party fails to remain consistent by lying or refusing to admit when a contradiction has occurred, the conversation should immediately end.
The goal of the speaker in a dialectical conversation should be to help their opponent fully understand their views. Once this goal is achieved, Socrates argues that a meaningful relationship between the two parties can be formed. However, he warns that if one party lies, tells half-truths, or misrepresents their views during the discourse, such a relationship cannot occur. Each participant must also speak their mind. If one participant holds back thoughts for fear of offending the other participant, they are holding back points that may be refuted or supported during the argument.
Bibliography
Aldea, Andreea Smaranda, et al. Phenomenology as Critique: Why Method Matters. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2022.
Ambury, James M. "Socrates (469–399 B.C.E.)." Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, www.iep.utm.edu/socrates. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
Barlas, Baran. "What Is Dialectic? From Heraclitus to Marx." The Collector, 21 Oct. 2023, www.thecollector.com/what-is-dialectic-heraclitus-marx. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
Belangia, Woody. "Rules for Socratic Dialectic." Plato: Gorgias, 2014, woodybelangia.com/2014/03/19/rules-for-socratic-dialectic. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
Brickhouse, Thomas, and Nicholas D. Smith. "Plato (427–347 B.C.E.)." Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, www.iep.utm.edu/plato. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
"Hegel's Dialectics." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2 Oct. 2020, plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel-dialectics. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
Mark, Joshua J. "Socrates." Ancient History Encyclopedia, 2 Sept. 2009, www.ancient.eu/socrates. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
"Socrates." History, 13 June 2023, www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/socrates. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.
"The Socratic Method." University of Chicago, www.law.uchicago.edu/socratic-method. Accessed 20 Nov. 2024.