Alcohol-related offenses

DEFINITION: Violations of the law in which consumption of alcohol is a fundamental component.

SIGNIFICANCE: Alcohol is a legally available drug that has significant impairing effects on a number of aspects of human cognition and performance. Given that alcohol is used pervasively among the general population, alcohol consumption is a significant element in a wide range of criminal cases. Alcohol may play a contributory role in a variety of offenses, even when the presence of alcohol at concentrations associated with significant intoxication does not form the basis of the offenses.

Ethanol, commonly referred to as alcohol, is a drug whose effects include depression of the function of the central nervous system (CNS). As is true for other CNS depressants, the severity of alcohol’s effects increases with dose, potentially causing significant impairment of psychomotor skills (such as those required for safe driving) and, ultimately, fatal respiratory depression or circulatory collapse.

Effects of Alcohol

At low blood alcohol concentrations (BACs), the effects of alcohol consumption include euphoria, talkativeness, and reductions in anxiety and inhibitions. At progressively greater BACs, speech may become slurred, and dizziness or a significant loss of coordination may be observed. Further increases to BAC may be accompanied by drowsiness, emotional lability, confusion, and loss of consciousness. Uncontrolled overdoses can result in fatal respiratory depression.

In addition to these relatively obvious symptoms, alcohol causes BAC-dependent impairment to a number of faculties related to psychomotor performance, including the ability to divide attention over multiple tasks, reaction time, risk or hazard perception, and motor coordination. All these faculties are essential for the safe operation of a motor vehicle. Consequently, one of the most obvious offenses directly related to alcohol consumption is impaired driving, or the operation of a motor vehicle with a BAC in excess of the legal limit. Despite the fact that the impairing effects of alcohol on the ability to drive safely have been extensively studied and publicized widely through various public education programs, the incidence of impaired driving offenses remains high in many jurisdictions.

Driving under the influence of alcohol is an example of an offense for which the consumption of alcohol and the associated intoxication form the basis of the offense. In some jurisdictions, other legal offenses are also premised specifically on alcohol consumption; these include public intoxication and the consumption of alcohol by minors.

The consumption of alcohol may also be associated with an increased probability of the occurrence of a number of other kinds of offenses. One such offense is sexual assault. A significant amount of research has examined the incidence of the use of drugs and alcohol in cases of sexual assault, especially those in which surreptitious drug administration (so-called drink spiking) is suspected. In a significant number of jurisdictions worldwide, the most common finding in such studies has been the presence of significant amounts of alcohol in the complainants. In cases of sexual assault, the consumption of alcohol by both the complainant and the assailant may be important. From the perspective of the complainant, alcohol suppresses behavioral inhibitions, possibly influencing decision-making skills or risk perception. Furthermore, excessive alcohol consumption often leads to substantial impairment and perhaps even unconsciousness, which can place an individual at considerable risk for attack. From the perspective of the assailant, alcohol’s suppression of behavioral inhibitions may also be dangerous, but further complications may take the form of alcohol’s interference with the perception of social cues.

Forensic Analysis and Interpretation of Evidence

Forensic analysis of the role of alcohol in a particular case typically requires an understanding of the extent of intoxication or impairment, which, in turn, is reflected by the BAC at the time of the incident. In practice, measurement of BAC involves the collection of blood samples or breath measurements, depending on the type of offense (for example, breath analysis is typically done in driving-related offenses, whereas blood sampling is generally done in the course of the examination of victims of sexual assault). Breath alcohol analysis uses instrumentation specifically designed for that particular purpose; analysis of blood samples is generally done by enzymatic methods or gas chromatography. Once a BAC measurement is made, a correction is usually applied to account for the amount of alcohol eliminated from the blood through metabolism and other processes between the time of the incident and the time of sample collection. This provides an estimated BAC range at the time of the incident, from which the likely extent of intoxication or impairment may be interpreted.

CNS function is enhanced when other depressant drugs are used in combination with alcohol, with potentially fatal consequences. Additionally, the combination of alcohol with other drugs not associated with CNS depression (such as or cannabis) may lead to significantly enhanced impairment or unexpected symptoms that may nonetheless contribute to some kinds of offenses. Consequently, more comprehensive forensic toxicological analysis may be warranted in some cases.

A 2023 study published in Frontiers in Psychology gave heavy drinkers alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages after witnessing a traumatic car accident. The study showed that they while both groups reported details immediately after the accident, the alcohol group benefitted from being interviewed a second time after one week had passed. The study concluded that this delayed interview was helpful when interviewing intoxicated witnesses.

Bibliography

"Alcohol-Related Crime." Addiction Center, 16 Apr. 2024, www.addictioncenter.com/alcohol/alcohol-related-crime. Accessed 14 Aug. 2024.

"Alcohol-Related Crimes." Alcohol Rehab Guide, 14 Nov. 2023, www.alcoholrehabguide.org/alcohol/crimes/. Accessed 14 Aug. 2024.

Baselt, Randall C. Drug Effects on Psychomotor Performance. Foster City, Calif.: Biomedical Publications, 2001.

Brunton, Laurence L., John S. Lazo, and Keith L. Parker, eds. Goodman and Gilman’s The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics. 11th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2006.

Garriott, James C., ed. Medical-Legal Aspects of Alcohol. 4th ed. Tucson, Ariz.: Lawyers & Judges Publishing, 2003.

Hagsand, Angelica V., et al. "The Impact of Alcohol and Drugs on Suspects', Victims', and Witnesses' Cognition and Memory." Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 14, 23 May 2023, doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1209406. Accessed 16 Aug. 2024.

Karch, Steven B., ed. Drug Abuse Handbook. 2d ed. Boca Raton, Fla.: CRC Press, 2007.

Levine, Barry, ed. Principles of Forensic Toxicology. 2d ed., rev. Washington, D.C.: American Association for Clinical Chemistry, 2006.