Coffin birth

Definition: Spontaneous delivery of a fetus from the uterus of a dead woman.

Significance: When a fetus is found outside the dead body of the mother, it may be necessary for forensic scientists to determine whether the mother died while the fetus was still in the uterus, the fetus later expelled by the buildup of decomposing gases in the mother’s body, or whether the fetus was delivered before the mother’s death and died separately. The distinction may be important when charges are brought against a suspect for the murder of a pregnant woman.

Although it has always been rare, the phenomenon of coffin birth, or postmortem birth, has occurred throughout history. Paleopathologists have discovered evidence of coffin birth (or Sarggeburt in German, the language in which it was first described) in archaeological digs in ancient graveyards. With modern embalming techniques, it has become even more unusual, although it still may occur in cases of accidental death, murder, or incorrect embalming practices.

Coffin birth is truly the birth of a fetus, not a case of the fetus being expelled through the body through the abdomen, such as with a wound mimicking a birth by cesarean section. The buildup of gases in the decomposing body of a pregnant woman may put pressure on the uterus to the point of expelling an unborn fetus through the birth canal. Scientists believe that this buildup could take weeks or months to happen, and the possibility of a coffin birth occurring depends on many outside factors, such as the air temperature and whether the woman’s body is in water or buried in the ground.

Coffin birth is so rare that it does not often appear in the medical literature. The topic came into the news spotlight in 2003, however, in the case of Laci Peterson. Peterson was about seven and one-half months pregnant when she disappeared in December, 2002, leading to speculation that her husband, Scott Peterson, had murdered her. Later, when her body and the body of her late-term fetus were found separately on the shores of the San Francisco Bay, coffin birth was raised as the possible reason that the fetus was no longer in her uterus. Coffin birth was only one possibility of many, but it was thought a strong possibility, partly because Laci Peterson had no external wounds consistent with the fetus’s exiting her body other than through the birth canal. Despite the confusion over whether she was still pregnant when she was killed or whether the baby was born before her death, charges were filed against Scott Peterson for the murder of both his wife and son. He was convicted in March, 2005, and sentenced to death for the murders.

Bibliography

Fleeman, Michael. Laci: Inside the Laci Peterson Murder. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2003.

Lyle, D. P. Forensics and Fiction: Clever, Intriguing, and Downright Odd Questions from Crime Writers. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2007.