Canadian immigrants

SIGNIFICANCE: Canadian immigration to the United States has historically been episodic and typically paralleled economic fluctuations and shifts in employment opportunities in one or the other of the neighboring countries. However, during the early twentieth century, many French-speaking Canadians immigrated to the United States to escape religious and political discrimination. 

Immigration into the territory of the future United States, from what were once called British North America and French Canada, began during the age of exploration and colonization when international borders were porous. Large-scale migration from French Canada began in 1755 with the expulsion of the Acadian French from Nova Scotia by Great Britain. There was little immigration from British North America after the American Revolution ended in 1783. Immigration to the United States from British North America did not significantly resume until the decade before the US Civil War (1861–1865) and continued to increase until 1890. The migration of French Canadians intensified from 1900 until 1930 to fill assembly lines in New England shoe and textile factories. The last major wave of Canadian immigration to the United States occurred between 1940 and 1990, after which Canadian immigration to the United States steadily declined. 

Immigration Before 1776

Exploration and colonization of the Americas and the region later known as Canada were undertaken by both French- and English-sponsored sea captains and companies. Borders between the French-Canadian province of Quebec and British-controlled areas of North America were ill-defined and porous. Consequently, explorers and settlers moved freely around North America’s rivers and lakes. French exploration reached as far south as the mouth of the Mississippi River, Pennsylvania, along the Great Lakes, and Lake Champlain. Geography and climate limited the population north of the Great Lakes to fur trappers and fishermen. Both Great Britain and France had difficulties attracting settlers to these northern regions. 

The English colonies in New England and Virginia were the fastest-growing regions where European immigrants were likely to settle because they afforded greater chances of economic success. In fact, the growing economic prosperity of England’s original thirteen colonies did lure an unrecorded number of settlers from the north. In 1745, New Englanders temporarily seized the French settlement and fortress of Louisbourg. Eighteenth-century rivalries between Great Britain and France ultimately led to Britain’s successful acquisition of Nova Scotia and the expulsion of an estimated 18,000 French-speaking Acadians to Britain’s Atlantic colonies between 1755 and 1763. This was after France’s withdrawal from North America in 1763, to Louisiana. The Acadian French of Louisiana were the first major immigration wave into the future United States from what would eventually become Canada. 

Immigration, 1776–1867

The resulting independence of the United States in 1783 led more than 35,000 United Empire Loyalists to emigrate from the United States to British North America. Britain’s Constitutional Act of 1791 split Quebec into territories named Upper and Lower Canada, each with its own assembly and council elected by its own people. The creation of the Hudson Bay Company to undertake fur trapping and settlement in the western regions of North America, was accompanied by the granting of increased political rights for Canadian settlers, lessening the desire of British subjects to go to the United States. 

The unsuccessful attempts by the United States during the War of 1812 to annex Upper and Lower Canada significantly strained relations between the neighboring countries and limited population movements from either direction. The Rush-Bagot Agreements of 1817 and 1818 demilitarized the border between the United States and Canada, permitting free and mostly unrecorded movements of people between the two countries. Low-cost land grants in 1815 to spur Canadian settlement proffered an economic boom that lasted several decades. This incentive attracted more than 800,000 immigrants to Canada between 1815 and 1850 and was termed the Great Migration. Other nineteenth-century developments that lessened incentives for Canadian settlers to move to the United States included the discovery of gold in the territory now known as British Columbia in 1858 and the building of canals and railroads connecting the different parts of British North America. 

Records kept by Canada’s Office of Immigration Statistics show only 209 people immigrated to the United States from Upper and Lower Canada and Newfoundland in 1820. Over the ensuing decade, 2,277 more Canadians made the move. The rate of British immigration to the United States from those territories increased in the succeeding decades—3,624 during the 1830s, 41,723 during the 1840s, and 59,309 during the 1850s. 

Immigration, 1867–1900

The U.S. Civil War severely strained relations between the United States, Great Britain, and Canada, which was still called British North America. Union blockades of Southern shipping during the war denied British textile factories the cotton they needed to operate. British attitudes toward immigrating to the United States changed after 1865 as the rapid industrialization of the country began generating a higher volume of manufacturing jobs that needed workers. The US Census of 1870 recorded that 478,685 immigrants from British North America were living in the United States. The majority of them settled in Massachusetts, New York State, Michigan, Maine, Vermont, Wisconsin, and Illinois. Each of these states bordered Canada, making frequent movements back and forth easy. 

In 1867, the British North American Act officially created the Dominion of Canada. At that time, Canada had the four provinces of Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia. The act created a federal government in Ottawa and provided a process to admit future provinces into the Canadian confederation. Although Canadians continued to move to the United States in succeeding decades, larger numbers of people from other parts of the world were immigrating to Canada to take advantage of inexpensive land in the western regions and to search for gold in the Yukon Territory. 

The 1880 U.S. Census listed 697,509 immigrants from British North America living in the United States, with the states of Massachusetts, Michigan, and New York as their principal destinations. In 1890, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, and Maine were the principal residences of the 978,219 immigrants from Canada and Newfoundland. Canadians were particularly drawn to rapidly industrializing U.S. states along the border. 

In 1900, the U.S. Census divided Canadian immigrants into English and French speakers. English-speaking immigrants numbered 747,050 and lived principally in Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, and Illinois, all industrial states. French speakers numbered 439,950, with Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, and California as their principal destinations. 

French Canadians in New England

Between 1900 and 1950, U.S. Census figures showed a substantial migration of French Canadians to the United States. The 1900 U.S. Census recorded 439,950 immigrants from Quebec were living in the United States, principally in New England. Many were motivated to emigrate because of a long history of discrimination in employment and educational opportunities under British rule. Moreover, raising money to buy farmland in Canada was becoming increasingly difficult. By contrast, employment opportunities in the United States expanded in the textile, shoemaking, and lumber industries throughout the Northeast. California’s expanding trade with Asia, the lure of mining jobs, and less expensive land to farm lured French Canadians to the West Coast of the United States. The first half of the twentieth century witnessed a large influx of French Canadians into New England. This region was home to 371,928 Canadians in 1910, 300,703 in 1920, 342,075 in 1930, and 381,302 in 1940. 

French Canadians also continued to settle in U.S. states bordering Canada. Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Michigan, Maine, and New York were their principal destinations. U.S. Census records from 1910, 1920, and 1930 divided Canadian immigrants into four categories: 

•Newfoundlanders (although Newfoundland was not part of Canada until 1949) 

•Canadians 

•Other Canadians 

•French-speaking Canadians 

During the year 1910, 1,934 Newfoundlanders were living in the United States, along with 784,063 "Other Canadians," 23,089 listed as Canadian, and 371,928 French speakers. The 1920 U.S. Census recorded 7,562 Newfoundlanders, 121,805 Canadians, 693,773 Other Canadians, and 300,712 French Canadians. The 1930 U.S. Census, taken during the first year of the Great Depression, listed 25,283 Newfoundlanders, 52,562 Canadians, 872,133 Other Canadians, and 342,072 French speakers. The increase in Canadians moving to the United States was explained by the migrants’ need to find work during the growing international financial crisis. 

After Great Britain entered World War II in 1939, many Canadians were drafted into the military to fight. Others went to the United States to find jobs in the expanding American war-based economy. The 1940 US Census counted 21,301 Newfoundlanders, 742,358 Canadians and 273,086 French Canadians living in the United States. As Canadian involvement in the war intensified, civilian and military job opportunities increased, and the number of Canadians going to the United States declined. The New England states of Massachusetts, Maine, and New Hampshire continued to attract the largest numbers of French-speaking Canadians. 

In parts of New England where French Canadians took up residence, new French-speaking Roman Catholic parishes created their own parochial schools, published French-language newspapers, and established French-owned businesses. Through several generations, French Canadian culture was preserved in neighborhoods that were essentially French speaking ethnic enclaves. Border-crossing documents have recorded members of New England’s French-speaking communities continued to move back and forth freely between the United States and Canada. Most Newfoundlanders who entered the United States between 1910 and 1940 resided in Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, New York, and Arkansas. Canadians other than French speakers and Newfoundlanders were principally located in New England, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Colorado, New Jersey, Washington, California, and Texas. 

Immigration After 1945

After World War II ended in 1945, Canadian immigration to the United States began a steady decline. Since the seventeenth century, the movement of Canadians to the United States was based on the need for jobs and better pay. The U.S. Census of 1950 no longer separated immigration statistics for Newfoundland, which had become a Canadian province. That census was also the last to distinguish between French-speaking and other Canadians. The number of French Canadians in the United States in 1950 was 159,187, principally residing in Massachusetts, New York, Michigan, and California. The number of "Other Canadians" in the United States who were recorded in the 1950 U.S. Census numbered 321,097. Massachusetts, New York, New Hampshire, and Michigan were their principal places of residence. U.S. Census tabulations over the next four decades showed 377,952 Canadian-born residents of the United States in 1960, 413,310 in 1970, 169,030 in 1980, 156,938 in 1990, and 191,987 in 2000. 

The decline in Canadian immigration after World War II was caused by a number of factors. After the war, Canada pursued more independent policies in foreign and domestic policies. During the early 1970s, Canada became a haven for Vietnam War protestors from the United States. Meanwhile, increasing numbers of American companies were establishing subsidiaries in Canada which made it less necessary to go to the United States to find automobile and other manufacturing jobs. Canada’s less costly universal health care system insured all Canadians for life, a sharp contrast with the health care system in the United States. Canada increasingly developed its own national identity separate from those of the United States and Great Britain. Canadian federal legislation has tended to foster policies that reflect Canadian innovations, greater tolerance of diversity, and a global agenda more compatible with the European Union than with the United States. All these developments made immigrating to the United States less attractive to Canadians. 

A parallel decline in the migration of French Canadians to the United States after World War II was due, in part, to the Canadian government’s granting of more political autonomy to French-speaking Quebec. This change has made it easier for French-speaking Canadians to preserve their language, culture, and Roman Catholic faith, all of which could be threatened if they were to move to the English-speaking United States. At the same time, the decline of the shoe, textile, and logging industries in New England and other US border states lessened the attraction of emigrating. 

Population movements between Canada and the United States were influenced by the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) Canada, the United States, and Mexico signed in 1993. NAFTA significantly reduced trade barriers between Canada and the United States and made it easier for Canadians to work in the United States on temporary visas. In 2006, for example, 64,633 Canadians worked in the United States on temporary employment visas, and another 13,136 were in the United States as their dependents. In contrast, during that same year, 24,830 US citizens worked in Canada on similar temporary visas. 

The U.S. Congress’s passage of the Patriot Act in 2001, after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, started a process that increasingly tightened border controls between Canada and the United States. Later amendments to the law for the first time began requiring people crossing the U.S.-Canadian border in either direction to carry passports. Heightened security at border crossings entailed closer scrutiny of travelers and more frequent searches of vehicles, creating unprecedented delays and increased stress, all of which have made border crossings less convenient. 

Despite the decline in Canadian immigration to the United States, Canadians have continued to see their southern neighbor as a land of greater economic opportunities, though to a lesser degree than in earlier years. Many Canadian athletes, actors, broadcasters, artists, writers, and corporate executives continued to work in the United States where their talents reach larger audiences and markets and where they earn higher incomes. Some Canadians also move to the United States in search of warmer climates. Additionally, in 2016, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security reported Canadians made up the largest group of those who illegally overstayed the length of visas for educational, business, or tourist purposes. The legacy of Canadian immigration to the United States remains embedded in American society due to its long history. In 2021, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey, 531,654 individuals reported Canadian ancestry.  

In 2022, The Washington Post conducted a study that showed a twenty-first-century correlation between U.S.-Canadian immigration patterns to the opposite country. The data demonstrated American migration into Canada increased during the Republican administration of President George W. Bush (2001-2009). Canadian immigration into the U.S. also spiked during this timeframe. Canadian immigration tapered off during President Barack Obama's years in office (2009-2017). Despite press reporting of large numbers of Americans seeking refuge in Canada during the presidential tenure of Donald Trump (2017-2021), this did not materialize. In 2018, Americans did outnumber Canadians in switching countries by a small margin. This was notable in that this had been a rare occurrence in the immigration histories of the two countries.  

The situation was dramatically reversed following the COVID-19 pandemic. In the first years of President Joe Biden's administration (2021-2024), Canadian immigration to the United States significantly increased compared to the previous decade, when a reported 126,340 Canadians moved to the US in 2022, an increase of 70 percent. This population displacement stemmed from several factors, including a chronic nationwide housing shortage in Canada, high home prices, and decreases in income. A house in Canada could, on average, and depending on location, cost more than 20 percent more than in the United States. Many other Canadians cited political disagreements with government policies and a reduced tax burden that came from relocating to the US. In 2022, Canadian arrivals were of three predominant groups: returned Americans, foreigners who migrated first to Canada, and those originally born in Canada.  

 

Bibliography

“2021: ACS 1-Year Estimates Selected Population Profiles.” U.S. Census Bureau, 2021, data.census.gov/table?q=canadian+ancestry. Accessed 21 Mar. 2023.

Amitverain. "Canada Faces Immigration Crisis 2024." Femmes Et Villes. 11 July 2024, femmesetvilles.org/canada-faces-immigration-crisis-2024. Accessed 8 Sept. 2024.

Attanasio, Cedar. "Canadian Immigrants Lead World in Illegal US Visa Overstays, According to First-Ever DHS Estimates." Latin Times, 4 Feb. 2016, www.latintimes.com/canadian-immigrants-lead-world-illegal-us-visa-overstays-according-first-ever-dhs-367906. Accessed 20 Oct. 2016.

Brault, Gerard J. The French-Canadian Heritage in New England. Hanover, University Press of New England, 1986.

Doty, C.S. The First Franco-Americans: New England Histories from the Federal Writers’ Project, 1938-39. University of Maine at Orono Press, 1985.

Faragher, John Mack. A Great and Noble Scheme. New York, W. W. Norton, 2005.

Hamilton, Janice. Canadians in America. Lerner, 2006.

McCullough, J.J. "Opinion Did Americans Really Move to Canada under Trump? Data Tells a Bigger Story." The Washington Post, 23 Aug. 2022, www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/08/23/canada-us-immigration-data-republican-presidents/. Accessed 8 Sept. 2024.

Ramirez, Bruno. Crossing the Forty-ninth Parallel. Cornell University Press, 2001.

Schideler, Janet L. Camille Lessard Bissonnette: The Quiet Evolution of French-Canadian Immigrants in New England. New York, Peter Lang, 1998.

Tasker, John Paul. "Emigration from Canada to the U.S. Hits a 10-Year High As Tens of Thousands Head South." CBC News, 30 May 2024, www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadians-moving-to-the-us-hits-10-year-high-1.7218479. Accessed 8 Sept. 2024.

Wade, M. The French Canadians, 1760-1967. MacMillan, 1968.

Zong, Jie. "Canadian Immigrants in the United States." Migration Policy Institute, 15 Sept. 2014, www.migrationpolicy.org/article/canadian-immigrants-united-states. Accessed 20 Oct. 2016.