Crimes of passion
Crimes of passion, or "crime passionnel," refer to offenses committed under intense emotional states like rage, jealousy, or despair, which severely impair the perpetrator's ability to think rationally. This concept is particularly relevant in legal contexts, as it helps differentiate between premeditated murder and lesser charges such as manslaughter. In cases deemed crimes of passion, the mental state of the offender is crucial in determining the severity of the crime. For example, if a person acts in response to significant provocation and lacks the time to regain self-control, this may mitigate their culpability. Historically, these cases often involved scenarios of infidelity, where a spouse commits violence upon discovering their partner's betrayal. However, contemporary views challenge the leniency afforded in such judgments, raising concerns about gender biases and the implications of allowing emotional reactions to justify violent acts. The nuances surrounding crimes of passion reflect broader societal values and encourage ongoing dialogue about justice, accountability, and the impact of emotions on human behavior.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Crimes of passion
SIGNIFICANCE: This concept is most frequently used in distinguishing the crime of murder, in which the killing is done with premeditation or malice aforethought, from the lesser crime of manslaughter.
One concept in determining the seriousness of a crime is the mental state of the perpetrator. A crime of passion, often known by the French term crime passionnel, is one committed under the influence of such strong feelings as rage, anger, hatred, furious resentment, wild desperation, or terror that occur so suddenly or extremely as to render the mind incapable of cool reflection. Such passion can be considered as a mitigating, although not an exonerating, factor.
The distinction between premeditated murder and manslaughter in American jurisprudence goes back to a Pennsylvania law enacted in 1794 to remove the death penalty from murders not considered willful, deliberate, and premeditated. If a killing follows from adequate provocation on the part of the victim and there is insufficient time for a reasonable person to have recovered self-control, the perpetrator is assumed to lack the mens rea , or evil intent, required for a murder charge.
To distinguish between a premeditated act and a crime of passion, all circumstances must be considered, including the length of time between the provocation and the crime, the manner in which the crime was committed, and the relationship between the parties. The application of this law has of course been influenced by contemporary mores. The traditional example of the homicidal crime of passion used to be the man who caught his wife in flagrante delicto (in the act) with another man. There was some disagreement as to whether this was an extenuating circumstance for killing the wife, the man, or both, but men who killed in that situation were often given minimal sentences on the grounds that they were impelled by their passions.
In modern America that approach is questioned. Feminists have argued that overly mild sentences in such cases all but license killing, and some would ask whether the supposedly masculine reaction of quick, angry violence should be privileged. Women, it is argued, are more likely to wait and build up courage before acting, and the “heat of passion” argument does not cover that. These issues came to the forefront in a Maryland case in 1994, when Kenneth Peacock was convicted for killing his wife. After catching his wife in an act of adultery, Peacock had argued with her for several hours, then shot her to death. He was allowed to use the crime-of-passion defense, pleading guilty to voluntary manslaughter. He was given a minimum three-year sentence with half of it suspended, a decision that brought widespread public criticism, especially when the judge publicly said that he might have done the same thing himself.
Bibliography
Appignanesi, Lisa. Trials of Passion: Crimes Committed in the Name of Love and Madness. New York: Pegasus, 2014. Print.
"Crime of Passion." Cornell Law School, July 2022, www.law.cornell.edu/wex/crime‗of‗passion. Accessed 25 June 2024.
Daly, Martin, and Margo Wilson. Homicide. New York: Gruyter, 1988. Print.
Engel, Howard. Crimes of Passion: An Unblinking Look at Murderous Love. Buffalo: Firefly, 2002. Print.
Geberth, Vernon J. Practical Homicide Investigation. 2nd ed. New York: Elsevier, 1990. Print.
Mandelsberg, Rose G., ed. Crimes of Passion: From the Files of True Detective. New York: Pinnacle, 1993. Print.