Shock collar
A shock collar, also known as an electronic collar or e-collar, is a training device primarily used for dogs. This collar delivers an electric shock as a corrective measure to deter unwanted behaviors such as excessive barking or aggression. Shock collars can come in various forms, including underground containment systems and remote training collars that allow owners to administer shocks manually. They were first introduced in the 1960s for hunting purposes and have since been adopted by pet owners for a range of training scenarios.
While proponents argue that shock collars can be effective training tools, critics highlight ethical concerns, claiming that their use can lead to physical harm and psychological issues in dogs. Opponents advocate for positive reinforcement techniques, suggesting that rewards such as treats or verbal praise are more humane and effective in modifying behavior. Despite the controversy, some owners find shock collars to be a cost-effective solution for managing their pets, especially in situations where professional training may be prohibitively expensive. Ultimately, shock collars represent just one method in a broader array of training techniques, and responsible usage is crucial to ensure the well-being of the animal.
On this Page
Shock collar
A shock collar—also known as an electronic collar, an e-collar, or a remote training collar—is a device used to train animals, mostly dogs. The device emits an electric shock to prevent bad behavior, such as excessive barking. Shock collars are also used to keep dogs in a contained area and for other training purposes. While they have been used since the 1960s to effectively train dogs and are considered safe, shock collars have been criticized for being inhumane. Opponents of the practice have suggested other training methods in lieu of using shock collars.
Overview
A shock collar is a collar that is fitted around a dog's neck. It delivers an electric shock to the animal via a small box called a receiver, which is outfitted with electrodes. The device is worn snuggly around the neck so the electrodes press through the dog's fur and into its skin. A shock is administered to the dog when the device is activated. These devices can operate at different levels, and some can transmit thousands of volts of electricity. Some collars emit tones or vibrations before a shock is administered.
Shock collars were invented in the 1960s to train dogs for hunting. Dog owners then began to use them to stop their pets from engaging in negative behaviors, such as aggression and barking. They also used them to train dogs to respond to certain commands.
Three types of shock collars exist: collars associated with containment or underground fences, remote training collars, and collars used to control barking. The way in which each works varies. An underground fence is a type of containment system, which is meant to keep a dog in a certain area. An underground wire is used to denote a perimeter that the dog is not permitted to cross. A transmitter emits a radio signal to the wire, which sends a volt of electricity to a battery-powered receiver placed on a dog collar. When a dog nears the boundary area, the receiver first gives the dog an audible warning sound. Sometimes the noise is enough to teach the dog not to cross into a particular area. However, once the dog steps over the boundary line, the transmitter sends a shock to the receiver on the collar to deter the dog from moving any farther.
These types of fences keep pets with receivers inside contained areas, but they do not keep out other animals that are not wearing shock collars. The transmitters must be plugged into a power source, and the receiver must have working batteries to operate. If the power source is lost, the underground fence will not work properly.
A remote training collar has a receiver on it that is connected to a portable remote-controlled transmitter. A person is able to control the transmitter and administer a shock to the dog to deter unwanted behavior. Some collars have warning sounds or vibrations prior to the shock. Owners use remote training collars to control their dogs. For example, an owner might use the collar to try to prevent a dog from jumping on guests. Some owners use them as negative reinforcement until the dog exhibits desirable behavior. In addition, they may be used to train dogs for hunting.
Another type of shock collar is used to deter a dog from barking. This device emits a shock in response to vocal cord vibrations felt when the dog barks. The shock is supposed to teach the dog to stop barking.
Pros and Cons
Some people are against using shock collars as a means to condition dogs. These critics contend that the collars serve as a form of punishment for dogs. They often argue that dog owners should try positive reinforcement in the form of rewards—such as treats, toys, or verbal encouragements—instead of negative reinforcement in the form of shocks to modify behavior. Opponents claim that some shock collars can cause physical harm and burns to animals, especially if the dogs are shocked at high levels.
People against shock collars may also believe that these devices can cause fear and anxiety in dogs. For example, if a dog is shocked because it is barking but the dog is lying in its bed at the time, it may learn to associate the shock with its bed and not the barking. This may cause the dog to refuse to lie in its bed. Dogs who are shocked outside at the site of underground fences may associate getting shocked with the yard itself and refuse to go outside.
Other people feel that shock collars can be effective training tools. Most collars have various shock levels and can be controlled so that the shock the dog receives does not harm it. Proponents also argue that the beep heard before the shock is delivered is sometimes enough to stop the dog from engaging in unwanted behavior. For example, some dogs learn not to engage in certain behaviors, such as not crossing into an unfenced area, when they hear the beep, so there is no need to shock them. However, opponents contend that dog owners could use other training tools, such as clickers that make a sound, to thwart bad behavior instead of shock collars. Still, some dog owners feel that shock collars offer faster results. The dog learns to stop negative behavior after a few shocks, and the collar is no longer needed. Affordability is another reason some owners turn to shock collars. Shock collars may be less expensive than hiring a professional dog trainer or going to obedience classes. Additionally, an underground fence typically costs much less than a regular fence would.
Shock collars can be used to control dogs when owners are not home to watch their pets. For example, anti-bark collars can help control dogs that bark too much when their owners leave. Underground fence collars can help dogs stay in their yards. Nevertheless, shock collars should not be used in an attempt to replace owner supervision. Dogs should not be left unattended for extended periods, especially outdoors.
Regardless of how a person feels about shock collars, they are just one training tool. Many other training methods exist. When training a dog, an owner should aim to get to the root of the negative behavior and try to find ways to redirect the dog's energy.
Bibliography
Braby, Emma. "Eight Things You Need to Know before Buying a Shock Collar." Canine Journal, 25 July 2024, www.caninejournal.com/shock-collar-for-dogs. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
Clarke, James Rhys. "Dog Shock Collars Controversy: What Do the Experts Say?" Top Dog Tips, 17 Jan. 2024, topdogtips.com/dog-shock-collars-controversy. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
"Electronic Fences and Shock Collars." People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, www.peta.org/living/companion-animals/caring-animal-companions/dogs/electric-fences-shock-collars. Accessed 22 Dec. 2016.
Kerns, Nancy. "Using Shock Collars for Dog Training – Is It Ok?" Whole Dog Journal, 8 July 2020, www.whole-dog-journal.com/blog/using-shock-collars-for-dog-training-is-it-ok/. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
Miller, Pat. "The Tools That Make Dog Training a Breeze." Whole Dog Journal, Feb. 2002, www.whole-dog-journal.com/issues/5‗2/features/5431-1.html. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
Russell-Ausley, Melissa. "How Underground Pet Fences Work." HowStuffWorks.com, 1 Apr. 2000, science.howstuffworks.com/innovation/everyday-innovations/pet-fence.htm. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
Schenker, Alex. "Is the Citronella Dog Collar a Safer Alternative to Electric Shock?" Canine Journal, 11 Oct. 2023, www.caninejournal.com/citronella-dog-collar. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.
“Which Type Collar for Dogs Is Best?” The Humane Society of the United States, www.humanesociety.org/resources/dog-collars. Accessed 28 Jan. 2025.